Question:

Isn’t this fun, Melody? First we have to put up with Bro Jack, then Mother Hickey comes back, now Elaine… Can anything else go wrong around here?  Do we have to get all the evil in usenet?  And just when I thought that things were getting back to normal. Georga – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Kids with no parents. Nice. > Almost like witches with no broom, huh? Why don’t you go find yours?

Response:

And if you are in Texas, you are free to e-mail me, also. I worked for the Texas Department of Human Services a few years ago, and I can answer questions you might have about Medicaid and other social services. Lisa * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

>i agree also, but my question is how in the hell is this woman supposed >to afford medical and/or professional help?

This is the type of situation that social services in most counties is best equipped to help with.  They typically have a sliding scale fee, from no cost to low-cost to market rate, based on income. If psychotropic medications become part of the equation, virtually every pharmaceutical house has a program to make these meds available free for those who need them but can’t afford to pay for them (contact your doctor for information and an application). It may take a few phone calls to figure out the right agency/person to talk to, but help SHOULD be there. Vicki H.

Response:

Or if you’re in georgia or tennessee I know all the ways to get free counseling & services in both places :) Melody – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > And if you are in Texas, you are free to e-mail me, also. I worked for > the Texas Department of Human Services a few years ago, and I can > answer questions you might have about Medicaid and other social > services. > Lisa > * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * > The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

You have already received some great advice, both in getting a routine installed and obtaining professional help.  One poster raised the question of payment for professional assistance.  If you are in the US and are unemployed it is probable that your children qualify for Medicaid.  If you don’t have it for them yet then apply.  The usual standard with Medicaid is that it is approved retroactively to the date of application.  You can even apply over the phone in many areas these days.  Secondly, most [if not all] US states offer Case Management services for children with mental and behavioral health needs.  One of the main qualifiers is that the child requires two or more coordinated mental health services.  Individual and family counseling qualifies as two separate services, and would probably be real helpful to you all at this point.  Find out what agency provides this service in your area and ask for a Case Manager for at least one of your children.  The Case Manager will help you by assessing what is going on, referring you and your family to appropriate service providers, following up until the services are in your home, monitoring the effectiveness of the services [and advocate for you if the need arises] and then gracefully bow out of your family’s life.  Since you sound just as overwhelmed as the children may also feel, having the assistance and support of a Case Manager might be just what you need to get over this hump and into services.  If you don’t know where to start looking for the Case Management agency, ask your version of Foster Care or the Medicaid Area Office [Case Management is a Medicaid reimbursed service].  If you are in Florida, email me and I may well be able to give much more specific information. Good luck.  You can make your way through this and bring your kids along with you, too. – Aula

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she > is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t > see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. > "Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a > hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which > we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by > Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of > finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter > began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare > entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really > bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. > money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, > running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with > compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". > she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only > not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve > recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for > 15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry > with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always > different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because > I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

>  Kids with no parents. Nice.

Almost like witches with no broom, huh? Why don’t you go find yours? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

If you want to get professional help for both you and your children, you might check out your local mental health authority (well, that’s what it’s called here in Texas). Services are based on income–and if you are charged for services and you can’t pay for them, they write it off. Our local mental health authority offers parenting classes a couple of times a week and works with parents and kids together and in seperate sessions. Also, in some cities, WIC offices offer parenting classes. I also agree with the advice from the other posters (well, except for you-know-who, of course). Get a routine down and set some rules and enforce them. It may not seem like you are getting anywhere for a while, but I am willing to bet that your kids will respond once they see that you are trying to help them feel better. Something to keep in mind–don’t let people get you down. Some people make it their business to kick you while you’re in the gutter. Ignore these people. Some people think that they are living some sort of charmed life and that they have all the answers. They aren’t and they don’t. I imagine that you are doing the best you can right now, and you ARE concerned, or you wouldn’t have posted here. That’s the first step–realizing the problem. The next move is yours, too. Get help. If there are no counseling services available that you can afford, try talking to a pastor. Some of the best advice I’ve ever received has been from my pastor. HTH, Lisa * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

 Kids with no parents. Nice. >You really are a bitch, arn’t you? >For your information, the best of parents can have the worst of kids due >to any variety of problems.  Get a life.  Better yet, get some kids and >find out for yourself before you go spouting off your crap. >Georga

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> >You’re not a bad mom. >  Geeze, if THIS is not a bad bunch of parents, I would hate to think what > was. Yuk! > You stuck by your kids, you want to help them. > >Most kids would be lucky to have a mom like you. > >The other posters have already said it. Get a routine going, write it > >down. Daily bedtimes, mealtimes, playtimes. Stick to it. A routine > >will give your kids something stable to count on. Once you have a > >routine going, it’s easier to tackle the individual issues. Show lots > >of unconditional love, no matter what, you have to keep showing your > >kids that you love them regardless of how they behave. > >If you can get professional help, go for it. If not, look for a local > >support group. The good news is that young kids can get over the tough > >times and bounce back. A bad start is usually that, just a bad start. > >You’ve got a long, rough road ahead, but you seem to have what it > >takes. > >Good luck > >Paul > >>HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but > she > >>is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I > don’t > >>see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two > years. > >>"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a > >>hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation > which > >>we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by > >>Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of > >>finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter > >>began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare > >>entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a > really > >>bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then > hidden. > >>money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, > >>running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems > with > >>compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". > >>she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, > only > >>not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve > >>recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for > >>15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry > >>with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always > >>different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy > because > >>I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > >>Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

Randy, No, she doesn’t have kids yet she hangs around here and every so often gives this kind of hateful advice. Georga – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a > daddy. They > don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have > no father. > These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently > lost her > father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a > chance for a > real homelife. > what the hell kind of advice is that? you want this lady to treat her > kids like dogs? take them to the pound when you can’t train them not to > pee on the carpet? oh, i get it, now. plain as day….you don’t have > kids do you? maybe you should experience things first before you go > spouting off (crappy) advice to others, ya think? > randy > >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not > ADD, but she > >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of > it".  I don’t > >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last > two > years. > >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll > them from a > >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week > probation > which > >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily > disowned by > >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because > of > >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my > daughter > >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed > from daycare > >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel > like a really > >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is > then hidden. > >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of > control, > >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has > problems with > >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just > because". > >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed > wetting, only > >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements > also. I’ve > >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen > timer for > >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is > he angry > >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers > are always > >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at > mommy > because > >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing. > * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * > The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

Elaine, You have out done yourself with insensitivity this time. Go to hell! Georga – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >  Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a daddy. They > don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have no father. > These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently lost her > father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a chance for a > real homelife. >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two > years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation > which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy > because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

You really are a bitch, arn’t you? For your information, the best of parents can have the worst of kids due to any variety of problems.  Get a life.  Better yet, get some kids and find out for yourself before you go spouting off your crap. Georga – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->You’re not a bad mom. >  Geeze, if THIS is not a bad bunch of parents, I would hate to think what > was. Yuk! > You stuck by your kids, you want to help them. >Most kids would be lucky to have a mom like you. >The other posters have already said it. Get a routine going, write it >down. Daily bedtimes, mealtimes, playtimes. Stick to it. A routine >will give your kids something stable to count on. Once you have a >routine going, it’s easier to tackle the individual issues. Show lots >of unconditional love, no matter what, you have to keep showing your >kids that you love them regardless of how they behave. >If you can get professional help, go for it. If not, look for a local >support group. The good news is that young kids can get over the tough >times and bounce back. A bad start is usually that, just a bad start. >You’ve got a long, rough road ahead, but you seem to have what it >takes. >Good luck >Paul >>HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but > she >>is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I > don’t >>see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two > years. >>"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >>hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation > which >>we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >>Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >>finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >>began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >>entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a > really >>bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then > hidden. >>money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >>running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems > with >>compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >>she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, > only >>not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >>recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >>15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >>with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >>different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy > because >>I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >>Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Wow, it sounds like things are very stressful in your house right > now! I > agree with everyone elses advice (except Elaine’s), you definitely > need > to seek professional help for both yourself AND your children. > In the meantime, think about it like this. Kids, the majority > anyway, > thrive on consistency and routine, your kids have neither. They > don’t > really have any control over what happens to them, so they are > reacting > in the only way they know how. You daughter is taking charge of > her life > and what happens to her (granted, it’s in a very negative way) in > the > only way she knows how. Your son is doing the same (it’s also > expected > that kids in really stressful situations will regress and if he’s > recently potty-trained, it’s reasonable that he is backsliding on > that). > Professionals can teach your kids very useful anger management > skills. > Sit down with your kids and talk to them (as a family or one at a > time, > whatever you think would be more manageable). Tell them what you > need, > find out what they need and work *together* to find a way to make > your > home a nice place to be. > Good luck!! > -Alexis > HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not > ADD, but she > is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of > it".  I don’t > see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the > last two years. > "Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll > them from a > hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week > probation which > we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily > disowned by > Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because > of > finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time > my daughter > began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed > from daycare > entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel > like a really > bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is > then hidden. > money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of > control, > running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has > problems with > compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just > because". > she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed > wetting, only > not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements > also. I’ve > recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen > timer for > 15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? > Is he angry > with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers > are always > different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at > mommy because > I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing. > Before you buy.

i agree also, but my question is how in the hell is this woman supposed to afford medical and/or professional help? i think that this woman is probably gonna have to either fix or at least start the problem solving herself. start with the ground rules idea mentioned by a previous poster, and make sure to spend time with your kiddos!! that is very important. but start with the rules and be consistent with them. if you threaten with a punishement, you better follow through. good luck… randy * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

>  Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a > daddy. They > don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have > no father. > These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently > lost her > father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a > chance for a > real homelife.

what the hell kind of advice is that? you want this lady to treat her kids like dogs? take them to the pound when you can’t train them not to pee on the carpet? oh, i get it, now. plain as day….you don’t have kids do you? maybe you should experience things first before you go spouting off (crappy) advice to others, ya think? randy – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not > ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of > it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last > two > years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll > them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week > probation > which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily > disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because > of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my > daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed > from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel > like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is > then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of > control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has > problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just > because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed > wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements > also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen > timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is > he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers > are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at > mommy > because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

>>You’re not a bad mom. > Geeze, if THIS is not a bad bunch of parents, I would hate to think what >was. Yuk!

Ha ha ha haa. :-) And what rock did you crawl out from under? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->You stuck by your kids, you want to help them. >Most kids would be lucky to have a mom like you. >The other posters have already said it. Get a routine going, write it >down. Daily bedtimes, mealtimes, playtimes. Stick to it. A routine >will give your kids something stable to count on. Once you have a >routine going, it’s easier to tackle the individual issues. Show lots >of unconditional love, no matter what, you have to keep showing your >kids that you love them regardless of how they behave. >If you can get professional help, go for it. If not, look for a local >support group. The good news is that young kids can get over the tough >times and bounce back. A bad start is usually that, just a bad start. >You’ve got a long, rough road ahead, but you seem to have what it >takes. >Good luck >Paul >>HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but >she >>is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I >don’t >>see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two >years. >>"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >>hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation >which >>we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >>Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >>finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >>began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >>entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a >really >>bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then >hidden. >>money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >>running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems >with >>compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >>she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, >only >>not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >>recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >>15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >>with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >>different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy >because >>I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >>Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

>You’re not a bad mom.

 Geeze, if THIS is not a bad bunch of parents, I would hate to think what was. Yuk! You stuck by your kids, you want to help them. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Most kids would be lucky to have a mom like you. >The other posters have already said it. Get a routine going, write it >down. Daily bedtimes, mealtimes, playtimes. Stick to it. A routine >will give your kids something stable to count on. Once you have a >routine going, it’s easier to tackle the individual issues. Show lots >of unconditional love, no matter what, you have to keep showing your >kids that you love them regardless of how they behave. >If you can get professional help, go for it. If not, look for a local >support group. The good news is that young kids can get over the tough >times and bounce back. A bad start is usually that, just a bad start. >You’ve got a long, rough road ahead, but you seem to have what it >takes. >Good luck >Paul >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

 Wouldn’t be much of a difference. They don’t have parents now. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a daddy. >They > don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have no >father. > These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently >lost her > father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a chance >for a > real homelife. > >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, >but she > >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I >don’t > >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two > years. > >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them >from a > >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week >probation > which > >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily >disowned by > >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of > >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my >daughter > >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from >daycare > >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a >really > >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then >hidden. > >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of >control, > >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has >problems with > >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just >because". > >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed >wetting, only > >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. >I’ve > >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen >timer for > >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he >angry > >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are >always > >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy > because > >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing. >You mean abandon them again eh?  Doesn’t sound like a solution to me. >Mike >Before you buy.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a daddy. They > don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have no father. > These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently lost her > father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a chance for a > real homelife. >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two > years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation > which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy > because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

You mean abandon them again eh?  Doesn’t sound like a solution to me. Mike Before you buy.

Response:

You’re not a bad mom. You stuck by your kids, you want to help them. Most kids would be lucky to have a mom like you. The other posters have already said it. Get a routine going, write it down. Daily bedtimes, mealtimes, playtimes. Stick to it. A routine will give your kids something stable to count on. Once you have a routine going, it’s easier to tackle the individual issues. Show lots of unconditional love, no matter what, you have to keep showing your kids that you love them regardless of how they behave. If you can get professional help, go for it. If not, look for a local support group. The good news is that young kids can get over the tough times and bounce back. A bad start is usually that, just a bad start. You’ve got a long, rough road ahead, but you seem to have what it takes. Good luck Paul – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

> Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a daddy. They >don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have no father. >These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently lost her >father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a chance for a >real homelife.

Heartless. How could you? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two >years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation >which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy >because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

Wow, it sounds like things are very stressful in your house right now! I agree with everyone elses advice (except Elaine’s), you definitely need to seek professional help for both yourself AND your children. In the meantime, think about it like this. Kids, the majority anyway, thrive on consistency and routine, your kids have neither. They don’t really have any control over what happens to them, so they are reacting in the only way they know how. You daughter is taking charge of her life and what happens to her (granted, it’s in a very negative way) in the only way she knows how. Your son is doing the same (it’s also expected that kids in really stressful situations will regress and if he’s recently potty-trained, it’s reasonable that he is backsliding on that). Professionals can teach your kids very useful anger management skills. Sit down with your kids and talk to them (as a family or one at a time, whatever you think would be more manageable). Tell them what you need, find out what they need and work *together* to find a way to make your home a nice place to be. Good luck!! -Alexis – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she > is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t > see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. > "Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a > hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which > we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by > Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of > finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter > began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare > entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really > bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. > money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, > running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with > compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". > she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only > not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve > recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for > 15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry > with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always > different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because > I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Before you buy.

Response:

You poor thing.  You really do have a situation.  You sound very busy with your hands full.  First I think I would set some ground rules. Start with behavior in the household. You need to have a daily routine and possibly spend more time one on one with your children and make them feel loved and special in their own way.  Even if it is 15min per child.  I think the child with the wetting problem is regressing for some reason.  I think I would get to the bottom of that immediately.  Just make quiet time and show your children that you love them.  Definetly set your house rules and routine and I think things will get better. Write it out and try different things.  Once you get all these things straight take some mommy time and relax. Reward yourself for a job well done.  Remember to be firm but lovable. I wish ou all the luck!! E-mail address is * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

I agree with you, Vicki.  It sounds like the whole situation has gotten out of control.  Some sort of psychological intervention my be in order, plus a parenting class.  Your little ones are crying out for help.  They seem to be emotionally distraught and it doesn’t seem that you have any idea where to start.  There really are too many problems here for this newsgroup to help with. You can go back through the archives to look for specific answers to specific problems.  Or even ask about one or two problems here.  But an honest attempt at a reply to all that you posted would take pages. One little comment, children will often pick up on their parents feelings and emotions.  How are you dealing with the abandonment and the lose of your job?  It might help all of you, if you too sought some counseling. I don’t think you are a bad mother.  You are honestly trying to find the right answers and are doing the best job that you know how.  That is all anyone can do.  You have made the first step in asking for help.  You should be congratulated for that.  But I think you are asking at the wrong place. Try the county mental health association, every county in the US should have one. Good luck, Heidi — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. > Yes, they have – enough changes to create big stresses in any > children. Have you taken the kids to a therapist or a psychologist? > Someone who could help determine to what extent their issues are based > on the chaotic changes and to what extent their issues may be based on > disorders, learning disabilities, etc. Also, why are you saying your 5 > yo is not ADD but is ‘clinically hyperactive’? Except in very obvious > cases, it may be early elementary school before it becomes clear that > a child has ADD, when the child has to function in a school > environment. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which >we failed to find a solution for). > That probation should tell you something – there is noticeable > difference in your daughter and the other kids. This is where you may > want a therapist to help you understand what is going on. >My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now. > Put yourself in her shoes – how does a small child handle being > ‘disowned by Dad’? > I love my children, but I feel like a really bad mom. > Then look around for parenting classes. Many communities make them > available for free. >My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing. > So why are you sure she has no ADD and ‘is growing out of it’? >My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" > A child that young can’t explain. He needs some medical help. > I have adopted children with disorders and a lot of experience in > volunteer organizations dealing with other families with similar > issues. Your children are crying our for some help that a professional > can help you with. If you have insurance, get a referral from the > pediatrician. If you don’t have insurance, contact your local mental > health referral agency and get a referral. They DO have therapists > available with sliding scales based on ability to pay. You and your > children need some help. > Vicki H.

Response:

HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. "Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for 15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

>HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years.

Yes, they have – enough changes to create big stresses in any children. Have you taken the kids to a therapist or a psychologist? Someone who could help determine to what extent their issues are based on the chaotic changes and to what extent their issues may be based on disorders, learning disabilities, etc. Also, why are you saying your 5 yo is not ADD but is ‘clinically hyperactive’? Except in very obvious cases, it may be early elementary school before it becomes clear that a child has ADD, when the child has to function in a school environment. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which >we failed to find a solution for).

That probation should tell you something – there is noticeable difference in your daughter and the other kids. This is where you may want a therapist to help you understand what is going on. >My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  

Put yourself in her shoes – how does a small child handle being ‘disowned by Dad’? > I love my children, but I feel like a really bad mom.  

Then look around for parenting classes. Many communities make them available for free. >My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  

So why are you sure she has no ADD and ‘is growing out of it’? >My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?"

A child that young can’t explain. He needs some medical help. I have adopted children with disorders and a lot of experience in volunteer organizations dealing with other families with similar issues. Your children are crying our for some help that a professional can help you with. If you have insurance, get a referral from the pediatrician. If you don’t have insurance, contact your local mental health referral agency and get a referral. They DO have therapists available with sliding scales based on ability to pay. You and your children need some help. Vicki H.

Response:

 Give them away. Find a real home for them with a mommy and a daddy. They don’t have any parents now. You’re at work all the time. The have no father. These are unloved, essentially feral children. The girl apparently lost her father and a step father. What a sad situation!  Give them a chance for a real homelife. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >HELP!! I have two children, ages 4 and 5. My 5 year old is not ADD, but she >is "clinically hyperactive" but "appears to be growing out of it".  I don’t >see this. The kids have been through a lot of changes in the last two years. >"Dad" walked out two years ago (literally). I had to disenroll them from a >hellish preschool (actually my daughter was given a two week probation which >we failed to find a solution for). My daughter was temporarily disowned by >Dad (not her biological father)-but that is better now.  Because of >finances, I changed daycare for both children at the same time my daughter >began Kindergarten, and just one month ago, they were removed from daycare >entirely because I got fired.  I love my children, but I feel like a really >bad mom.  My 4 year old steals. food from the pantry, which is then hidden. >money from my dresser, just to hold it.  My daughter is out of control, >running, yelling (it’s like she HAS to create noise). She has problems with >compulsions, i.e.., walking past brother and smacking him "just because". >she is a controlling, bossy thing.  My son, BIG problem!! Bed wetting, only >not always in bed.  And, in the last two weeks, bowel movements also. I’ve >recently gone to goodnites and today I tried setting the kitchen timer for >15 minutes. He went "poop" in between!!  How is that possible? Is he angry >with me for all these changes? I tried asking him, the answers are always >different and none agree with what I’m asking; "Are you mad at mommy because >I can’t take you to Tracy’s (babysitter) anymore?" >Any suggestions or just Mom insight would be a blessing.

Response:

Question:

> The sister’s priority is her crotch. >I continue to be amazed at the cruel remarks made in here.

 Too bad it’s true. It sure is not my choice to spit out babies, then trot off to some far flung part of the world to let someone else raise them as they may…  My God, she asked >for help in a very long post and this is the best you can come up with?

 Uhm, EXCUSE me, but exactly what did you think could be done after the fact? The kids are here, and very real. You can’t hardly send them back, restructure them genetically, or pick better fathers for them at this late date. I feel for everyone involved with the exception of those userous men.  After the fact, all someone can "come up with" is to say that if you’re going to have children, spend a couple of days thinking about what kind of fathers and husbands those men will make. It’s too late for this horny chick. The best anyone can hope for is some other girl will take a lesson when she starts leading with the groin.

Response:

The problem with trying to address a post like this one is that it seems that no advice will work until your sister begins to address her own neediness and problems.   While parenting classes might help give her some of the skills she needs they will not address the underlying problems of her own pain. While I don’t know if she can get any help for free where she is, I would suggest that she look at both therapy for herself and some kind to family therapy to work on her relationship with her children. That said, give her as much support to parent the boys in positive ways as you can.  Maybe she would consider having someone help her control her *yelling* by letting her know when she was close to the edge and helping her give herself a time-out when she felt angry enough to yell. Perhaps she can remind herself to count to 10 whenever she feels the anger coming on. Help her to find ways to set limits that she can live with instead of waiting until the behavior drives her nuts to take action.  If she reads, perhaps 1,2,3 Magic might be a decent book on discipline to get her started. I’m not a big fan of this method, but for someone who has no control, it may help.  Help her learn to use positive language, model that with her whenever she calls and maybe see if you can find some other moms their who can help her also.  Maybe there is a group of moms she can be friends with whose parenting skills she admires? Dorothy – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild.  Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Response:

>>I think she would be open to things, if she was approached the right way. >She is very closed minded and if I do it wrong then she will never look at >any option again.  But I think my opinion on that may stem from T. Jones >response that I am enabling her. >These are still good boys. > Don’t know what is your definition of "good".  They’re probably exactly >like each of their separate black fathers. G o n e  once they get their >jollies.

So you are no good, just like your mother, Elaine.  Geez, you are incredible. Dorothy

Response:

Sounds like your sister needs to learn some new parenting skills. From what you discribe (IMO) your sister is in need of some counciling to learn to handle her emotional needs on her own, insteed of using her children. Also, the 7 year old has some serious issues going on that therapy might help before long term damage is done. Being 500 miles away there is not much you can do beyond giving your sister your advise, which she can always choose not to take. The only other thing you could possibly do is call Child Protction Services (or what ever it is called in your area) and explain the situation. I called Child Welfare on a cousin of mine. She had no parenting skills, wasn’t open to help, and had two kids with worsening behavior and emotional problems. The family got counciling, one child was found to be ADHD, and she got parenting classes & child support collection help (she had been recieving nothing until she got a social worker involved.) My cousin never learned who called on her (though she does suspect both my self and her mother.) At first she was made as a wet hen, but after things started setling down and she realized they were trying to help her (even though she had to be forced into excepting it) not trying to take her children she got over being mad. She now says it was one of the best things to ever happen to her. Liz

Response:

Elaine, get help, will you. Mean, huh? You spout racist nonsense and expect me not to return your venom right back on you?  My family has many different races in it, Elaine.  I will not allow anyone like you to get away with this kind of idiocy. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Dorothy Sacks and her infamous mean streak.  She can act SO nice sometimes, >but watch out! >>Like that is a kind of constructive criticism that anyone will give >>credibility too. >>Thanks, but no thanks. >Don’t worry about Elaine.  She’s just the local troll.  No kids.  No life. >Likes to kick dogs.  You know the type. >Dorothy

Response:

Of course not, you don’t have any tots, thank heaven. Dorothy > Oh, please- shame on ME?  I didn’t make then abandon two innocent little >boys. I didn’t lay the care of said tots on my elderly, guilt ridden mother. >Get real.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->That was quite racist.  Shame on you. >>  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of >> animals. >>  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white >women >> with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. >Keep it >> that way to retain your sanity. >> >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly >out of >> >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say. >However, >> >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >> >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious >problem >> >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >> >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >> >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation >that I >> >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see >something >> that >> >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on >my >> >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >> >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial >(Jamaican >> and >> >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he >was >> >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to >Jamaica >> >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the >past.  He >> >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a >> younger >> >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his >father >> >every other weekend. >> >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until >> >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at >them, often >> >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are >being >> >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both >boys to >> >sleep and they often sleep with her. >> >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. >> >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, >lending, etc. >> >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted >to buy >> >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday >> >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs >them to >> >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of >her >> >behavior.) >> >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control >over any >> >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. >> >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. >For no >> >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or >even his >> >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >> >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past >post, >> mine >> >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know >very >> well. >> >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of >my >> >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this >age >> with >> >an adult he may only see once a year.) >> >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to >visit >> >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew >started >> >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for >a time >> >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer >room as >> he >> >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started >screaming >> >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then >said, in >> >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 >1/2 yo >> >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then >said >> to >> >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to >pee."  My >> >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he >does >> >that." >> >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should >> >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told >her >> >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next >morning, she >> >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >> >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious >what I >> >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about >it?  Is >> >there anything that can be done? >> >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple >math >> at >> >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good >lucking.  He >> >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn >into. >> >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one >ideal >> >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly >> appreciated. >> >Thanx so very much. >> >Heidi >> >– >> >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me >and my >> >family. >Before you buy.

Response:

> The sister’s priority is her crotch.

I continue to be amazed at the cruel remarks made in here. My God, she asked for help in a very long post and this is the best you can come up with? Geeze……why didn’t ya just `think` it at her and spare the rest of us your gutter remark? Josie

Response:

Nikki, Thanx for all the input.  I talked to her tonight and told her some of the things that were said on here (the constructive things).  She seemed more open than I thought she would be.  She said she was going to contact the County Mental Health Dept.  to see what she can get done.  I think I even talked her into counseling for herself (got my fingers crossed).  I have printed up your suggestions and sent her a copy via e-mail, along with a couple of others who sent suggestions to me personally. They are family and I love them very much.  It is extremely hard to see someone you love in a downward spiral.  I don’t know how people can handle situations like this in their own families if it was a worse situation, say drugs or alcohol. Thank you for you kind words. Heidi — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Well some of these things may or may not work – just some ideas.  You’ll > know if they are worth while for your sisters situation. > ~ Counseling for her individually and for the family unit > ~ Counseling for the 7 year old.  Tuff to have a missing dad. > ~ Where I live there are Mental Health agencies that offer this on a sliding > fee scale if insurance doesn’t cover it.  They will also come to a persons > house to help with strategies of how to deal with behavior concerns, > parenting techniques etc. > ~ Big Brother program an option for 7 year old?  Scouts – anything positive > like that? > ~ Can she set up a meeting with the school, for a couple of reasons.  He > sounds really smart – better to keep him challenged then to let him get > bored and the school will probably see some behavior problems and she’ll > already have a repore going. > ~ Evaluation by a doctor or psychiatrist for the 7 year old.  He sounds like > quite a hand full.  This might just be because of his parenting but the lack > of impulse control etc could be something else.  It is hard to sort that all > out.  If there is a diagnosis of some sort he may be eligible for an IEP in > school, which forces them to come up with some kind of plan on how to work > with him instead of just suspending him. > ~ I’m peripherally aware of a similar situation.  The boys behavior > deteriorated until the school agreed to pay for a short term (2mos I think) > placement in a residential facility that managed his meds, did some > counseling, and set up a behavior program.  The biggest benefit was the work > they did with the mother so that she could effectively parent him when he > returned home.  Hope it doesn’t get that far for your sis. You could make > some phone calls and get information together so that it doesn’t seem so > overwhelming for your sis but it would of course be her call if she followed > through with any of it.  Let me know if this doesn’t make any sense to you > :-) > Good luck – Nikki >I think she would be open to things, if she was approached the right > way.<snip>

Response:

Yes, shame on you for thinking that we are any different!  We make the same mistakes they do.  It has nothing to do with colour or race.  Be real. >  Oh, please- shame on ME?  I didn’t make then abandon two innocent little > boys. I didn’t lay the care of said tots on my elderly, guilt ridden mother. > Get real.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->That was quite racist.  Shame on you. >>  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of >> animals. >>  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white >women >> with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. >Keep it >> that way to retain your sanity. >> >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly >out of >> >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say. >However, >> >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >> >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious >problem >> >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >> >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >> >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation >that I >> >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see >something >> that >> >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on >my >> >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >> >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial >(Jamaican >> and >> >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he >was >> >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to >Jamaica >> >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the >past.  He >> >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a >> younger >> >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his >father >> >every other weekend. >> >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until >> >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at >them, often >> >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are >being >> >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both >boys to >> >sleep and they often sleep with her. >> >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. >> >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, >lending, etc. >> >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted >to buy >> >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday >> >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs >them to >> >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of >her >> >behavior.) >> >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control >over any >> >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. >> >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. >For no >> >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or >even his >> >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >> >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past >post, >> mine >> >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know >very >> well. >> >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of >my >> >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this >age >> with >> >an adult he may only see once a year.) >> >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to >visit >> >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew >started >> >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for >a time >> >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer >room as >> he >> >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started >screaming >> >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then >said, in >> >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 >1/2 yo >> >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then >said >> to >> >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to >pee."  My >> >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he >does >> >that." >> >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should >> >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told >her >> >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next >morning, she >> >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >> >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious >what I >> >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about >it?  Is >> >there anything that can be done? >> >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple >math >> at >> >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good >lucking.  He >> >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn >into. >> >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one >ideal >> >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly >> appreciated. >> >Thanx so very much. >> >Heidi >> >– >> >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me >and my >> >family. >Before you buy.

Before you buy.

Response:

Well some of these things may or may not work – just some ideas.  You’ll know if they are worth while for your sisters situation. ~ Counseling for her individually and for the family unit ~ Counseling for the 7 year old.  Tuff to have a missing dad. ~ Where I live there are Mental Health agencies that offer this on a sliding fee scale if insurance doesn’t cover it.  They will also come to a persons house to help with strategies of how to deal with behavior concerns, parenting techniques etc. ~ Big Brother program an option for 7 year old?  Scouts – anything positive like that? ~ Can she set up a meeting with the school, for a couple of reasons.  He sounds really smart – better to keep him challenged then to let him get bored and the school will probably see some behavior problems and she’ll already have a repore going. ~ Evaluation by a doctor or psychiatrist for the 7 year old.  He sounds like quite a hand full.  This might just be because of his parenting but the lack of impulse control etc could be something else.  It is hard to sort that all out.  If there is a diagnosis of some sort he may be eligible for an IEP in school, which forces them to come up with some kind of plan on how to work with him instead of just suspending him. ~ I’m peripherally aware of a similar situation.  The boys behavior deteriorated until the school agreed to pay for a short term (2mos I think) placement in a residential facility that managed his meds, did some counseling, and set up a behavior program.  The biggest benefit was the work they did with the mother so that she could effectively parent him when he returned home.  Hope it doesn’t get that far for your sis. You could make some phone calls and get information together so that it doesn’t seem so overwhelming for your sis but it would of course be her call if she followed through with any of it.  Let me know if this doesn’t make any sense to you :-) Good luck – Nikki >I think she would be open to things, if she was approached the right

way.<snip>

Response:

Oh I see…so this NEVER happens in all white families, right? Tampamom > Oh, please- shame on ME?  I didn’t make then abandon two innocent little >boys. I didn’t lay the care of said tots on my elderly, guilt ridden mother. >Get real.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->That was quite racist.  Shame on you. >>  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of >> animals. >>  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white >women >> with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. >Keep it >> that way to retain your sanity. >> >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly >out of >> >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say. >However, >> >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >> >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious >problem >> >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >> >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >> >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation >that I >> >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see >something >> that >> >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on >my >> >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >> >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial >(Jamaican >> and >> >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he >was >> >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to >Jamaica >> >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the >past.  He >> >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a >> younger >> >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his >father >> >every other weekend. >> >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until >> >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at >them, often >> >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are >being >> >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both >boys to >> >sleep and they often sleep with her. >> >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. >> >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, >lending, etc. >> >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted >to buy >> >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday >> >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs >them to >> >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of >her >> >behavior.) >> >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control >over any >> >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. >> >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. >For no >> >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or >even his >> >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >> >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past >post, >> mine >> >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know >very >> well. >> >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of >my >> >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this >age >> with >> >an adult he may only see once a year.) >> >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to >visit >> >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew >started >> >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for >a time >> >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer >room as >> he >> >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started >screaming >> >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then >said, in >> >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 >1/2 yo >> >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then >said >> to >> >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to >pee."  My >> >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he >does >> >that." >> >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should >> >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told >her >> >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next >morning, she >> >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >> >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious >what I >> >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about >it?  Is >> >there anything that can be done? >> >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple >math >> at >> >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good >lucking.  He >> >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn >into. >> >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one >ideal >> >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly >> appreciated. >> >Thanx so very much. >> >Heidi >> >– >> >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me >and my >> >family. >Before you buy.

Response:

>I think she would be open to things, if she was approached the right way. >She is very closed minded and if I do it wrong then she will never look at >any option again.  But I think my opinion on that may stem from T. Jones >response that I am enabling her. >These are still good boys.

 Don’t know what is your definition of "good".  They’re probably exactly like each of their separate black fathers. G o n e  once they get their jollies. They just need lots of help.  I want to get it – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->for them, before they are no longer good boys. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family. > Wow – hard situation.  Is your sister open/willing to look into outside >help > or change at all.  If she is there are probably some things you could do, > even from 500 miles away, that could get her started down the right path >but > she has to be willing to follow through or at least get started.  Does she > even see a problem?  If you think she would pursue some things I can throw > out a few ideas.  If not – sad to say I can’t think of much you can do. >If > things continue as is she runs the risk (high IMO) of her kids ending up >in > the social service system or corrections before much longer. > Nikki K. > >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of > >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, > >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem > >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I > >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something > that > >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my > >part,  PLEASE, let me know. > >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican > and > >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was > >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica > >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past. He > >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger > >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father > >every other weekend. > >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until > >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, >often > >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being > >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to > >sleep and they often sleep with her. > >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. > >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, >etc. > >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to >buy > >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday > >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them >to > >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her > >behavior.) > >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over >any > >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. > >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For >no > >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his > >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, > mine > >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very > well. > >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my > >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age > with > >an adult he may only see once a year.) > >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit > >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started > >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a >time > >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as > he > >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming > >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in > >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo > >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said > to > >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee." My > >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does > >that." > >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should > >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her > >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, >she > >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what >I > >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it? Is > >there anything that can be done? > >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math > at > >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. >He > >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. > >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal > >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. > >Thanx so very much. > >Heidi > >– > >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and >my > >family.

Response:

 Oh, please- shame on ME?  I didn’t make then abandon two innocent little boys. I didn’t lay the care of said tots on my elderly, guilt ridden mother. Get real. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >That was quite racist.  Shame on you. >  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of > animals. >  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white >women > with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. >Keep it > that way to retain your sanity. > >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly >out of > >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say. >However, > >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious >problem > >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation >that I > >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see >something > that > >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on >my > >part,  PLEASE, let me know. > >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial >(Jamaican > and > >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he >was > >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to >Jamaica > >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the >past.  He > >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger > >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his >father > >every other weekend. > >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until > >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at >them, often > >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are >being > >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both >boys to > >sleep and they often sleep with her. > >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. > >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, >lending, etc. > >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted >to buy > >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday > >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs >them to > >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of >her > >behavior.) > >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control >over any > >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. > >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. >For no > >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or >even his > >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past >post, > mine > >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know >very > well. > >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of >my > >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this >age > with > >an adult he may only see once a year.) > >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to >visit > >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew >started > >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for >a time > >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer >room as > he > >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started >screaming > >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then >said, in > >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 >1/2 yo > >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then >said > to > >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to >pee."  My > >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he >does > >that." > >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should > >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told >her > >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next >morning, she > >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious >what I > >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about >it?  Is > >there anything that can be done? > >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple >math > at > >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good >lucking.  He > >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn >into. > >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one >ideal > >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. > >Thanx so very much. > >Heidi > >– > >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me >and my > >family. >Before you buy.

Response:

>Like that is a kind of constructive criticism that anyone will give >credibility too. >Thanks, but no thanks.

Don’t worry about Elaine.  She’s just the local troll.  No kids.  No life. Likes to kick dogs.  You know the type. Dorothy

Response:

That was quite racist.  Shame on you. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of > animals. >  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white women > with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. Keep it > that way to retain your sanity. >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say. However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something > that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican > and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, > mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very > well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age > with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as > he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said > to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math > at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Before you buy.

Response:

 Black males are everybody’s true enemy. Even their own women hate them. In Africa, all the black males do is fight and reproduce. Traditionally, negro women and men are adversaries, enemies. The frequently plot and sometimes succeed  killing their "husbands". Not that they have marriages as marriage is known in the west.  Usually, the families are matricentral, with women forming the core of the family, and men coming and going at will. Just like the black dicks that your sister "entertains". – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Like that is a kind of constructive criticism that anyone will give >credibility too. >Thanks, but no thanks. >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family. >  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of > animals. >  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white women > with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. Keep >it > that way to retain your sanity. > >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of > >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, > >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem > >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I > >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something > that > >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my > >part,  PLEASE, let me know. > >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican > and > >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was > >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica > >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past. He > >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger > >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father > >every other weekend. > >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. >Until > >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, >often > >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being > >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to > >sleep and they often sleep with her. > >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative >person. > >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, >etc. > >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to >buy > >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a >birthday > >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them >to > >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her > >behavior.) > >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over >any > >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female >student. > >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For >no > >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his > >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, > mine > >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very > well. > >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my > >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age > with > >an adult he may only see once a year.) > >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit > >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started > >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a >time > >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as > he > >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming > >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in > >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo > >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said > to > >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee." My > >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does > >that." > >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* >should > >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her > >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, >she > >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what >I > >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it? Is > >there anything that can be done? > >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math > at > >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. >He > >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. > >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal > >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. > >Thanx so very much. > >Heidi > >– > >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and >my > >family.

Response:

 Dorothy Sacks and her infamous mean streak.  She can act SO nice sometimes, but watch out! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Like that is a kind of constructive criticism that anyone will give >credibility too. >Thanks, but no thanks. >Don’t worry about Elaine.  She’s just the local troll.  No kids.  No life. >Likes to kick dogs.  You know the type. >Dorothy

Response:

 The sister’s priority is her crotch. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Gosh, I see many problems, but first, IANAD so here’s what I see from the >parents’ sidelines.  You and your family enable.  Don’t take offense, we do that >with people we love and it takes an outsider making us mad by saying it to get >us to see it.  Your sister will get mad as hell at you when you stop letting her >get away with bad behavior, and her sons will suffer for it, but she does not >have any right to upset your family and household.  Her sons will suffer for her >lack of parenting all their lives.  You can’t change that.  She can, but >probably won’t.  If they become too violent, the state will take them away from >her.  Your parents and your siblings should NOT step in to prevent this. She >will hate you for it.  But if you step in and take the boys in, they will >manipulate you mercilessly and tear your house up and tear your family apart. >Your first obligation is NOT to your sister and her boys–that’s HER >responsibility, whether she accepts it or not.  Yours is to your family, and if >you "help" her, your family will suffer. >I hate to be so blunt about it, but this is textbook social work history. She >is abdicating responsibility because her priorities aren’t her children. If you >or anyone in your family attempts to take up this responsibility, you will not >end up with two unruly kids in your house.  You will end up with her kids >tearing up the house and your own kids imitating the behavior they see the other >kids getting away with.  There is no happy ending to family intervention here. >She needs help, and it’s out there, but she has to want it and go after it >herself.  The best you can do is tell her so. > I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of > boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, > tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem > with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I > don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that > I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my > part,  PLEASE, let me know. > They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and > Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was > called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica > immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He > came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger > brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father > every other weekend. > My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. Until > she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often > resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being > good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to > sleep and they often sleep with her. > She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. > She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. > She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy > Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday > present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to > make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her > behavior.) > Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any > of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. > The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no > apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his > mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine > cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. > Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my > nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with > an adult he may only see once a year.) > I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit > this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started > throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time > out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he > has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming > like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in > hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo > followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to > me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My > sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does > that." > That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should > fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her > where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she > said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I > think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is > there anything that can be done? > This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at > 4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. He > has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. > There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal > solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. > Thanx so very much. > Heidi > — > Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my > family.

Response:

I think she would be open to things, if she was approached the right way. She is very closed minded and if I do it wrong then she will never look at any option again.  But I think my opinion on that may stem from T. Jones response that I am enabling her. These are still good boys.  They just need lots of help.  I want to get it for them, before they are no longer good boys. Heidi — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Wow – hard situation.  Is your sister open/willing to look into outside help > or change at all.  If she is there are probably some things you could do, > even from 500 miles away, that could get her started down the right path but > she has to be willing to follow through or at least get started.  Does she > even see a problem?  If you think she would pursue some things I can throw > out a few ideas.  If not – sad to say I can’t think of much you can do. If > things continue as is she runs the risk (high IMO) of her kids ending up in > the social service system or corrections before much longer. > Nikki K. >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something > that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican > and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, > mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very > well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age > with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as > he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said > to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math > at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Response:

Like that is a kind of constructive criticism that anyone will give credibility too. Thanks, but no thanks. — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->  Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of > animals. >  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white women > with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. Keep it > that way to retain your sanity. >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something > that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican > and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a > younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, > mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very > well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age > with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as > he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said > to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math > at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly > appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Response:

Wow – hard situation.  Is your sister open/willing to look into outside help or change at all.  If she is there are probably some things you could do, even from 500 miles away, that could get her started down the right path but she has to be willing to follow through or at least get started.  Does she even see a problem?  If you think she would pursue some things I can throw out a few ideas.  If not – sad to say I can’t think of much you can do.  If things continue as is she runs the risk (high IMO) of her kids ending up in the social service system or corrections before much longer. Nikki K. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild.  Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Response:

I read your post a couple times to make sure I got all that you were saying. I think you are right that we are enabling her.  I have known that for sometime about my mother.  I never saw it in me.  So, I had to stop and think about what you said.  Then, I had to think about the advise I gave her last night.  And you are totally right.  I didn’t want to hurt her feelings so I pussy footed around what really needed to be said to her. I think you are wrong on bringing the boys into my home.  I would love to do this for them on the condition that they are mine for always.  I think they are still young enough that some sort of stable intervention would help. But since there is little chance of her allowing this, you are probably right on this too. I also think you are wrong in that there is nothing that can be done.  I just can’t allow myself to believe this.  There must be some program somewhere that could intervene. Why is it so common in our society to say "Well it is just the parents fault and their responsibility."  and then when the child shots up the school during lunch we say, "We as the community should do more.  If the parents can’t handle this kid, why don’t we have a system to intervene." We can’t have it both ways.  Something needs to be done with kids like this early, before more tragedy occurs. Anyway, writing all of this out and thinking about it through the night has really opened my eyes even more.  Thank you all for the forum. Heidi — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Gosh, I see many problems, but first, IANAD so here’s what I see from the > parents’ sidelines.  You and your family enable.  Don’t take offense, we do that > with people we love and it takes an outsider making us mad by saying it to get > us to see it.  Your sister will get mad as hell at you when you stop letting her > get away with bad behavior, and her sons will suffer for it, but she does not > have any right to upset your family and household.  Her sons will suffer for her > lack of parenting all their lives.  You can’t change that.  She can, but > probably won’t.  If they become too violent, the state will take them away from > her.  Your parents and your siblings should NOT step in to prevent this. She > will hate you for it.  But if you step in and take the boys in, they will > manipulate you mercilessly and tear your house up and tear your family apart. > Your first obligation is NOT to your sister and her boys–that’s HER > responsibility, whether she accepts it or not.  Yours is to your family, and if > you "help" her, your family will suffer. > I hate to be so blunt about it, but this is textbook social work history. She > is abdicating responsibility because her priorities aren’t her children. If you > or anyone in your family attempts to take up this responsibility, you will not > end up with two unruly kids in your house.  You will end up with her kids > tearing up the house and your own kids imitating the behavior they see the other > kids getting away with.  There is no happy ending to family intervention here. > She needs help, and it’s out there, but she has to want it and go after it > herself.  The best you can do is tell her so. > I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of > boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, > tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem > with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I > don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that > I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my > part,  PLEASE, let me know. > They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and > Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was > called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica > immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past. He > came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger > brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father > every other weekend. > My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild. Until > she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often > resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being > good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to > sleep and they often sleep with her. > She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. > She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. > She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy > Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday > present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to > make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her > behavior.) > Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any > of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. > The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no > apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his > mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine > cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. > Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my > nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with > an adult he may only see once a year.) > I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit > this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started > throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time > out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he > has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming > like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in > hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo > followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to > me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee." My > sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does > that." > That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should > fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her > where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she > said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I > think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it? Is > there anything that can be done? > This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at > 4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking. He > has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. > There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal > solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. > Thanx so very much. > Heidi > — > Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my > family.

Response:

 Your sister, her black sperm donors and her whole brood are a pack of animals.  You’re not going to change her. This situation is typical for white women with a thing for black you-know-what. Good thing she’s 500 mi. away. Keep it that way to retain your sanity. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of >boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, >tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. >Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem >with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. >I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the >problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I >don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that >I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my >part,  PLEASE, let me know. >They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and >Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was >called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica >immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He >came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger >brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father >every other weekend. >My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild.  Until >she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often >resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being >good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to >sleep and they often sleep with her. >She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. >She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. >She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy >Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday >present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to >make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her >behavior.) >Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any >of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. >The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no >apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his >mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries >excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine >cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. >Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my >nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with >an adult he may only see once a year.) >I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit >this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started >throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time >out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he >has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming >like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in >hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo >followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to >me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My >sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does >that." >That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should >fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her >where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she >said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." >I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I >think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is >there anything that can be done? >This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at >4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He >has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. >There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal >solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. >Thanx so very much. >Heidi >– >Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my >family.

Response:

Gosh, I see many problems, but first, IANAD so here’s what I see from the parents’ sidelines.  You and your family enable.  Don’t take offense, we do that with people we love and it takes an outsider making us mad by saying it to get us to see it.  Your sister will get mad as hell at you when you stop letting her get away with bad behavior, and her sons will suffer for it, but she does not have any right to upset your family and household.  Her sons will suffer for her lack of parenting all their lives.  You can’t change that.  She can, but probably won’t.  If they become too violent, the state will take them away from her.  Your parents and your siblings should NOT step in to prevent this.  She will hate you for it.  But if you step in and take the boys in, they will manipulate you mercilessly and tear your house up and tear your family apart. Your first obligation is NOT to your sister and her boys–that’s HER responsibility, whether she accepts it or not.  Yours is to your family, and if you "help" her, your family will suffer. I hate to be so blunt about it, but this is textbook social work history.  She is abdicating responsibility because her priorities aren’t her children.  If you or anyone in your family attempts to take up this responsibility, you will not end up with two unruly kids in your house.  You will end up with her kids tearing up the house and your own kids imitating the behavior they see the other kids getting away with.  There is no happy ending to family intervention here. She needs help, and it’s out there, but she has to want it and go after it herself.  The best you can do is tell her so. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of > boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, > tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. > Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem > with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. > I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the > problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I > don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that > I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my > part,  PLEASE, let me know. > They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and > Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was > called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica > immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He > came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger > brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father > every other weekend. > My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild.  Until > she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often > resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being > good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to > sleep and they often sleep with her. > She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. > She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. > She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy > Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday > present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to > make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her > behavior.) > Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any > of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. > The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no > apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his > mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries > excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine > cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. > Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my > nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with > an adult he may only see once a year.) > I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit > this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started > throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time > out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he > has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming > like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in > hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo > followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to > me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My > sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does > that." > That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should > fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her > where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she > said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." > I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I > think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is > there anything that can be done? > This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at > 4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He > has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. > There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal > solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. > Thanx so very much. > Heidi > — > Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my > family.

Response:

I know I have started a couple of threads lately.  I posted mostly out of boredom and wanted to see what other moms and dads had to say.  However, tonight I really need some sound advise on a serious matter. Tonight one of my sisters called and she is having a very serious problem with her 1st grade son.  He will be 7 in the spring. I will give a very brief history and then a brief explanation of the problem.  But please be advised, this is my opinion of a situation that I don’t live next to.  We live 500 miles apart.  So, if you see something that I may have missed or something that is a blatant misunderstanding on my part,  PLEASE, let me know. They live in a mostly white town and my nephew is inter-racial (Jamaican and Caucasian).  The only remark that we know of being said to him is he was called Cousin Skeeter from Nickelodeon.  His father went back to Jamaica immediately after he was born.  He has only called twice in the past.  He came to visit this summer and hasn’t called since.   My nephew has a younger brother (African-American and Caucasian) who goes and visits his father every other weekend. My sister’s parenting skills are very limited.  Both boys run wild.  Until she can’t stand it any longer and then she yells and screams at them, often resulting in spanking and jerking the child around.  When they are being good, she over compensates and babies them.  She still rocks both boys to sleep and they often sleep with her. She is a very, very needy person.  She also is a very manipulative person. She uses guilt to bully my mother into babysitting, taxiing, lending, etc. She even told me she would have her 7yo tell Grandma that he wanted to buy Mommy a gift but didn’t have any money.  This way she would get a birthday present.  She uses her children like a security blanket.  She needs them to make her feel needed. (This last statement is my interpretation of her behavior.) Anyway, my nephew wets the bed every night.  He has little control over any of his impulses.  Today was the second time he bit a fellow female student. The note from school said if it happens again he will be suspended. For no apparent reason, he will loose control and attack his brother or even his mother (hitting, kicking, screaming, shoving.)  He whines and cries excessively (more than my 13 month old and if you remember a past post, mine cries quit a bit.)  He is very clingy with adults he doesn’t know very well. Especially, us family members.  (I am not turned off by affection of my nieces and nephew, but it is extremely excessive in a child of this age with an adult he may only see once a year.) I will give you an example of what I have witnessed.  They came to visit this summer.  Sister went out with other sister shopping.  Nephew started throwing a screaming fit over something.  I sent him to my room for a time out until he could calm down.  (Couldn’t send him to the computer room as he has a tendency to tear a room apart if he is mad.)  He started screaming like a mad man. I went to go see what the problem was.  He then said, in hysterics, he had to pee.  (I know he had just gone, because my 2 1/2 yo followed him in.)  I said no. He proceeded to pee on my bed and then said to me in an instantly calm and snide voice,  "See, I said I HAD to pee."  My sister laughed about this and said, "Gee, I should have told you he does that." That night, she ran out of the over night pants and told me that *I* should fix the bed he was sleeping on so that he doesn’t wet on it.  I told her where the supplies were and how *she* should do it.  The next morning, she said, "*You* might want to change the sheets, he peed on the bed." I think it is pretty obvious what the problem is or at least obvious what I think the problem is.  My question is what the HELL do I do about it?  Is there anything that can be done? This little boy is extremely smart.  He was reading and doing simple math at 4yo.  He will be a very handsome man someday.  He is very good lucking.  He has a good heart.  But I am very afraid of what he is going to turn into. There are many, many problems here and I know that there isn’t one ideal solution.  But any suggestions or new insights would be greatly appreciated. Thanx so very much. Heidi — Would you like a home-based business?  Ask me what is working for me and my family.

Response:

Question:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Leonie, > Now at ten years old you would think that she will know this will hurt > her dad.  That’s why I feel that something should be said, however > small. > You’re right, I’m sure this 10-year-old did know she was hurting her father with > her comment, but then again I’m sure that was what she intended.  The relationship > between this girl and her dad is clearly marked by tension, but this is normal. > His daughter is striking out against her father, probably in part to hear his > reaffirmation of his love for her, but also partly because she’s hurting inside. > Nothing can help that except the tincture of time… > Jennifer

My husband arrived home yesterday so I discussed this with him and it turns out that his mum has talked a bit about the situation to him and mentioned that it was the ex-wife having an affair which caused the marriage to break up.  I’m sure it wasn’t exactly as simple as that but it struck me interesting as from what I could tell, K heavily blames her father for this.  Oh dear, the plot thickens. — Leonie Lawson Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Leonie, > I think you are a caring person to be involved in the girls’ welfare, but I > don’t think you have "a right to butt in," as you put it.  Obviously you > have concerns about your input as well, since you’ve refrained so far from > conversing with D re:  his daughters. > I am a step-parent as well as a bio-parent, and I post regularly on > alt.support.step-parents.  I think you would get excellent feedback on that > NG. > If you absolutely feel you need to speak to anyone, I would suggest you > share your concerns with your mother-in-law (or have your husband do so). > She is certainly in a better position to relate those (or her own) concerns > to D. > But having read scores of posts from step-parents, I can assure you that > most of the fireworks you’ve described seems completely ordinary.  D appears > to be doing the best he can to be a good father to his kids, and your best > choice would probably be to support him by praising his skills, assisting > him when you can, and showing the girls a lot of kindness and affection. > Jennifer

Thanks Jennifer for your input.  I appreciate it as you have more knowledge of these situations than I and this is exactly what I was after.  I think you are right in voicing any concerns I have to my mother in law.  She is definitely in a better position to introduce advice to her boyfriend than me. I forgot to write this example down but the other thing that is going on is that K seems to try to hurt her dad intentionally.  eg. It was Fathers Day not too long ago and D naturally wanted to spend that weekend with his girls.  It wasn’t his scheduled weekend so he rang up his ex to arrange it and talked to K first.  He suggested the idea to her and she said "Why?  We want to spend that day with Bruce (name of ex’s new boyfriend I think) instead.  He’s more like our father." Now at ten years old you would think that she will know this will hurt her dad.  That’s why I feel that something should be said, however small. Thanks again. — Leonie Lawson Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > A close friend of mine is in a similar situation to the father you have > mentioned.   What a lot of mothers dont realise is that most homes dont have > sound-proof walls and mothers airing their hatred of their ‘ex’ on the phone > or over a cuppa with a friend can quite easily be heard by a slightly > confused child.   My friend discovered that something was seriously wrong > when upon introducing his daughter to his "new" girlfriend (he waited for 6 > months before he introduced them to ensure that his relationship was in fact > long term)   Upon meeting the woman, the daughter announced that she was not > going to like her because she was a "swamp donkey".   This was how the > ‘ex-wife’ referred to her around her friends.   After many heated > discussions with the ‘ex-wife’, the father managed to pursuade her to sit > down with him and the daughter and talk about their breakup and how daddy > wasn’t an ‘asshole on legs’ which was a term the daughter used towards her > father more than once, and the ‘ex-wife’ promised to make an attempt to keep > her badmouthing of the father to herself (or at best to only badmouth him > when the daughter was not in the house). > A simple, slightly bitter, comment when shopping with a friend and her > daughter could be the source of the problem eg: mother might be looking at > an expensive dress, friend prompts her to buy it, mother replies "if ‘D’ > didnt take half of my money when he left, I might be able to afford it", > daughter hears comment, takes it a little too literally, and there is a > problem developing at lightning speed. > Intervention in such a delicate situation could prove a bit messy. > Depending on how well you get on with the father of the child, perhaps > relaying ‘losely’ what she told you might make him investigate where her > hatred has come from, and he might be able to discuss it with the mother > (although dont lay blame automatically onto the mother, grandparents and > family friends can be just as guilty of this). > People need to realise that just because they hate their ex-spouse the child > does not need to follow suit, and children normally grow up with similar > opinions as their parents.   Be careful what you are saying, who you are > saying it about, and who can hear you next time.

Thanks Julie.  Unfortunately this scenario sounds more common then we’d all like to think.  I didn’t mean to lay all the blame on the mother, that wasn’t my intention, it just seemed to me that it was one possible place where the distorted truth could have come from, although the way you described it through thin walls sounds the most likeliest explanation. I actually think that the relationship between the ex’s is fairly civil but of course I don’t know what is said behind closed doors. I think that I may talk to my mother in law about this and then wait and see.  I also might print out these responses for her as she may find them quite helpful as well.  Thanks again for sharing your story. — Leonie Lawson Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

A close friend of mine is in a similar situation to the father you have mentioned.   What a lot of mothers dont realise is that most homes dont have sound-proof walls and mothers airing their hatred of their ‘ex’ on the phone or over a cuppa with a friend can quite easily be heard by a slightly confused child.   My friend discovered that something was seriously wrong when upon introducing his daughter to his "new" girlfriend (he waited for 6 months before he introduced them to ensure that his relationship was in fact long term)   Upon meeting the woman, the daughter announced that she was not going to like her because she was a "swamp donkey".   This was how the ‘ex-wife’ referred to her around her friends.   After many heated discussions with the ‘ex-wife’, the father managed to pursuade her to sit down with him and the daughter and talk about their breakup and how daddy wasn’t an ‘asshole on legs’ which was a term the daughter used towards her father more than once, and the ‘ex-wife’ promised to make an attempt to keep her badmouthing of the father to herself (or at best to only badmouth him when the daughter was not in the house). A simple, slightly bitter, comment when shopping with a friend and her daughter could be the source of the problem eg: mother might be looking at an expensive dress, friend prompts her to buy it, mother replies "if ‘D’ didnt take half of my money when he left, I might be able to afford it", daughter hears comment, takes it a little too literally, and there is a problem developing at lightning speed. Intervention in such a delicate situation could prove a bit messy. Depending on how well you get on with the father of the child, perhaps relaying ‘losely’ what she told you might make him investigate where her hatred has come from, and he might be able to discuss it with the mother (although dont lay blame automatically onto the mother, grandparents and family friends can be just as guilty of this). People need to realise that just because they hate their ex-spouse the child does not need to follow suit, and children normally grow up with similar opinions as their parents.   Be careful what you are saying, who you are saying it about, and who can hear you next time.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Hi guys, > Okay, this could get quite long but I would love to hear some opinions > on this situation.  A little background first: this is mostly about my > mother in law (G), and more about her boyfriend (D) and his two > daughters (K – age 10) and (N – age 8).  D is separated from the mother > of K and N and the mother has custody while D gets the girls every > second weekend. > Today G asked me and Maia and Casta to go with them to a farm park’s > open day.  Sounded like a good time so we all went.  This was the first > time that I’d met K and N.  K wanted to come with me in our car and so > the others went off first.  I like kids and I love talking to them but I > must admit I was quite saddened to hear some of the things this wee girl > was saying. > She started talking about her mum and how her dad and her had split up. > She then went on to say: "I don’t know if I should tell you this, you’ve > got to promise not to tell my dad but, dad’s not a very nice man.  He > broke up with my mum and then had a girlfriend who was really nice but > she wanted to get married and he didn’t because he’d been married twice > before so they split up, and now he’s with G.  All I can say is that she > should be warned." > It went on: "I don’t like my dad, it was his fault that we had to move > from our house because he wanted his half of the money.  Even though mum > did a lot of work and put in heaps of stuff for me, like the pool.  He > never loved me as a kid.  He wanted to leave when I was young but mum > asked him to stay a bit longer for us girls.  He doesn’t like me." > At this point I tried to explain that as a parent I could pretty much > say that this wasn’t true, and besides he’s talked a lot about her to us > and it is not talk of a man who doesn’t love his daughter.  She wasn’t > really listening though. > Now, this was my first encounter with this young girl and she didn’t > know me from a bar of soap but she obviously needs a neutral party > (preferably young I think) who she can talk to.  I think that’s why she > told me these private thoughts.  My reaction (after I’d had a time to > think about it) is that this girl hasn’t handled the separation of her > parents very well and hasn’t been told the facts as to why the marriage > broke up – I mean the real facts.  I would also guess that she has > overheard snippets of conversation and moulded it into her own version > of the way it all happened and the result is that everything was dad’s > fault. > To be fair to her, I also don’t think that seeing one’s children every > two weeks is enough, especially at this crucial age, and that rejection > (for want of a better word) could be manifesting in some way as well. > Also, from what I could see today, D doesn’t seem to be that clued up as > to what makes a young girls life go around.  An example of this is that > at one point K went off to enter a painting competition and we all > patiently waited for her for about 1/2 an hour.  D kept sending N to > hurry her up which was a job she clearly didn’t like (K is very much the > bossy outspoken sister whereas N is very quiet and lovely in nature) and > eventually I volunteered to go and get her to give N a break. > I got her and she was all excited as she was very proud of her picture > and told me that we had to be back at 2pm (in two hours time) for the > chance of winning prizes.  I started to tell her that we were getting > ready to go home as Casta needed a nap and so she ran straight to dad to > ask him if we could all stay.  He said ‘no’ with an explanation why and > then we all started off.  K sat down and cried, refusing to move.  D > kept walking and so I felt something needed to be said so I went back > and suggested that she tell them she can’t come back but to leave her > name and phone number in ase she wins.  This was done and all seemed > fine but then she must’ve said something else to D because they both > went back again.  When they came back she was yelling "I hate you dad" > and then wouldn’t speak to anyone. > Now from what G tells me, this behaviour is a common occurrence when D > has the girls.  Apparently it seems to D that he has to take his girls > out somewhere every fortnight because he feels sorry for them and the > situation they’ve been put in.  Then there’s always something that blows > up.  Wanting another ice-cream when the money’s been spent etc. > Wow, sorry this is so long. > Okay, this is what I see.  K needs a friend to talk to and she also > needs her parents (preferably both of them together) to explain their > breakup and other issues that she has a problem with.  D needs to learn > a bit more about his daughters and also needs to make more time to see > them more often, parenting classes could be a good thing there. > Hopefully if this happens then N won’t follow in her sister’s footsteps > and start hating dad.  Today she was dad’s best friend but G tells me > that other days she acts just like K. > Basically, do I have a right to butt in?  I feel that even talking to D > could be way out of line.  I think I will discuss this with G and my > husband Kieron and maybe they will have some good thoughts but I see > that these people need something to happen now before it manifests into > something bigger and uglier – I’m just unsure of my footing.  D is a > very nice and generous man.  He is amazing with my girls, they love him > to bits, he is a bit shy and he is an old dad (50 I think) which may be > a factor.  I have had no deep talks with him before, I’ve only seen him > about 6 or 7 times I think.  So what do you all think? > Thanks in advance, > — > Leonie Lawson > Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) > dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

Leonie, I think you are a caring person to be involved in the girls’ welfare, but I don’t think you have "a right to butt in," as you put it.  Obviously you have concerns about your input as well, since you’ve refrained so far from conversing with D re:  his daughters. I am a step-parent as well as a bio-parent, and I post regularly on alt.support.step-parents.  I think you would get excellent feedback on that NG. If you absolutely feel you need to speak to anyone, I would suggest you share your concerns with your mother-in-law (or have your husband do so). She is certainly in a better position to relate those (or her own) concerns to D. But having read scores of posts from step-parents, I can assure you that most of the fireworks you’ve described seems completely ordinary.  D appears to be doing the best he can to be a good father to his kids, and your best choice would probably be to support him by praising his skills, assisting him when you can, and showing the girls a lot of kindness and affection. Jennifer – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Hi guys, > Okay, this could get quite long but I would love to hear some opinions > on this situation.  A little background first: this is mostly about my > mother in law (G), and more about her boyfriend (D) and his two > daughters (K – age 10) and (N – age 8).  D is separated from the mother > of K and N and the mother has custody while D gets the girls every > second weekend. > Today G asked me and Maia and Casta to go with them to a farm park’s > open day.  Sounded like a good time so we all went.  This was the first > time that I’d met K and N.  K wanted to come with me in our car and so > the others went off first.  I like kids and I love talking to them but I > must admit I was quite saddened to hear some of the things this wee girl > was saying. > She started talking about her mum and how her dad and her had split up. > She then went on to say: "I don’t know if I should tell you this, you’ve > got to promise not to tell my dad but, dad’s not a very nice man.  He > broke up with my mum and then had a girlfriend who was really nice but > she wanted to get married and he didn’t because he’d been married twice > before so they split up, and now he’s with G.  All I can say is that she > should be warned." > It went on: "I don’t like my dad, it was his fault that we had to move > from our house because he wanted his half of the money.  Even though mum > did a lot of work and put in heaps of stuff for me, like the pool.  He > never loved me as a kid.  He wanted to leave when I was young but mum > asked him to stay a bit longer for us girls.  He doesn’t like me." > At this point I tried to explain that as a parent I could pretty much > say that this wasn’t true, and besides he’s talked a lot about her to us > and it is not talk of a man who doesn’t love his daughter.  She wasn’t > really listening though. > Now, this was my first encounter with this young girl and she didn’t > know me from a bar of soap but she obviously needs a neutral party > (preferably young I think) who she can talk to.  I think that’s why she > told me these private thoughts.  My reaction (after I’d had a time to > think about it) is that this girl hasn’t handled the separation of her > parents very well and hasn’t been told the facts as to why the marriage > broke up – I mean the real facts.  I would also guess that she has > overheard snippets of conversation and moulded it into her own version > of the way it all happened and the result is that everything was dad’s > fault. > To be fair to her, I also don’t think that seeing one’s children every > two weeks is enough, especially at this crucial age, and that rejection > (for want of a better word) could be manifesting in some way as well. > Also, from what I could see today, D doesn’t seem to be that clued up as > to what makes a young girls life go around.  An example of this is that > at one point K went off to enter a painting competition and we all > patiently waited for her for about 1/2 an hour.  D kept sending N to > hurry her up which was a job she clearly didn’t like (K is very much the > bossy outspoken sister whereas N is very quiet and lovely in nature) and > eventually I volunteered to go and get her to give N a break. > I got her and she was all excited as she was very proud of her picture > and told me that we had to be back at 2pm (in two hours time) for the > chance of winning prizes.  I started to tell her that we were getting > ready to go home as Casta needed a nap and so she ran straight to dad to > ask him if we could all stay.  He said ‘no’ with an explanation why and > then we all started off.  K sat down and cried, refusing to move.  D > kept walking and so I felt something needed to be said so I went back > and suggested that she tell them she can’t come back but to leave her > name and phone number in ase she wins.  This was done and all seemed > fine but then she must’ve said something else to D because they both > went back again.  When they came back she was yelling "I hate you dad" > and then wouldn’t speak to anyone. > Now from what G tells me, this behaviour is a common occurrence when D > has the girls.  Apparently it seems to D that he has to take his girls > out somewhere every fortnight because he feels sorry for them and the > situation they’ve been put in.  Then there’s always something that blows > up.  Wanting another ice-cream when the money’s been spent etc. > Wow, sorry this is so long. > Okay, this is what I see.  K needs a friend to talk to and she also > needs her parents (preferably both of them together) to explain their > breakup and other issues that she has a problem with.  D needs to learn > a bit more about his daughters and also needs to make more time to see > them more often, parenting classes could be a good thing there. > Hopefully if this happens then N won’t follow in her sister’s footsteps > and start hating dad.  Today she was dad’s best friend but G tells me > that other days she acts just like K. > Basically, do I have a right to butt in?  I feel that even talking to D > could be way out of line.  I think I will discuss this with G and my > husband Kieron and maybe they will have some good thoughts but I see > that these people need something to happen now before it manifests into > something bigger and uglier – I’m just unsure of my footing.  D is a > very nice and generous man.  He is amazing with my girls, they love him > to bits, he is a bit shy and he is an old dad (50 I think) which may be > a factor.  I have had no deep talks with him before, I’ve only seen him > about 6 or 7 times I think.  So what do you all think? > Thanks in advance, > — > Leonie Lawson > Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) > dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

Hi guys, Okay, this could get quite long but I would love to hear some opinions on this situation.  A little background first: this is mostly about my mother in law (G), and more about her boyfriend (D) and his two daughters (K – age 10) and (N – age 8).  D is separated from the mother of K and N and the mother has custody while D gets the girls every second weekend. Today G asked me and Maia and Casta to go with them to a farm park’s open day.  Sounded like a good time so we all went.  This was the first time that I’d met K and N.  K wanted to come with me in our car and so the others went off first.  I like kids and I love talking to them but I must admit I was quite saddened to hear some of the things this wee girl was saying. She started talking about her mum and how her dad and her had split up. She then went on to say: "I don’t know if I should tell you this, you’ve got to promise not to tell my dad but, dad’s not a very nice man.  He broke up with my mum and then had a girlfriend who was really nice but she wanted to get married and he didn’t because he’d been married twice before so they split up, and now he’s with G.  All I can say is that she should be warned." It went on: "I don’t like my dad, it was his fault that we had to move from our house because he wanted his half of the money.  Even though mum did a lot of work and put in heaps of stuff for me, like the pool.  He never loved me as a kid.  He wanted to leave when I was young but mum asked him to stay a bit longer for us girls.  He doesn’t like me." At this point I tried to explain that as a parent I could pretty much say that this wasn’t true, and besides he’s talked a lot about her to us and it is not talk of a man who doesn’t love his daughter.  She wasn’t really listening though. Now, this was my first encounter with this young girl and she didn’t know me from a bar of soap but she obviously needs a neutral party (preferably young I think) who she can talk to.  I think that’s why she told me these private thoughts.  My reaction (after I’d had a time to think about it) is that this girl hasn’t handled the separation of her parents very well and hasn’t been told the facts as to why the marriage broke up – I mean the real facts.  I would also guess that she has overheard snippets of conversation and moulded it into her own version of the way it all happened and the result is that everything was dad’s fault. To be fair to her, I also don’t think that seeing one’s children every two weeks is enough, especially at this crucial age, and that rejection (for want of a better word) could be manifesting in some way as well. Also, from what I could see today, D doesn’t seem to be that clued up as to what makes a young girls life go around.  An example of this is that at one point K went off to enter a painting competition and we all patiently waited for her for about 1/2 an hour.  D kept sending N to hurry her up which was a job she clearly didn’t like (K is very much the bossy outspoken sister whereas N is very quiet and lovely in nature) and eventually I volunteered to go and get her to give N a break. I got her and she was all excited as she was very proud of her picture and told me that we had to be back at 2pm (in two hours time) for the chance of winning prizes.  I started to tell her that we were getting ready to go home as Casta needed a nap and so she ran straight to dad to ask him if we could all stay.  He said ‘no’ with an explanation why and then we all started off.  K sat down and cried, refusing to move.  D kept walking and so I felt something needed to be said so I went back and suggested that she tell them she can’t come back but to leave her name and phone number in ase she wins.  This was done and all seemed fine but then she must’ve said something else to D because they both went back again.  When they came back she was yelling "I hate you dad" and then wouldn’t speak to anyone. Now from what G tells me, this behaviour is a common occurrence when D has the girls.  Apparently it seems to D that he has to take his girls out somewhere every fortnight because he feels sorry for them and the situation they’ve been put in.  Then there’s always something that blows up.  Wanting another ice-cream when the money’s been spent etc. Wow, sorry this is so long. Okay, this is what I see.  K needs a friend to talk to and she also needs her parents (preferably both of them together) to explain their breakup and other issues that she has a problem with.  D needs to learn a bit more about his daughters and also needs to make more time to see them more often, parenting classes could be a good thing there. Hopefully if this happens then N won’t follow in her sister’s footsteps and start hating dad.  Today she was dad’s best friend but G tells me that other days she acts just like K. Basically, do I have a right to butt in?  I feel that even talking to D could be way out of line.  I think I will discuss this with G and my husband Kieron and maybe they will have some good thoughts but I see that these people need something to happen now before it manifests into something bigger and uglier – I’m just unsure of my footing.  D is a very nice and generous man.  He is amazing with my girls, they love him to bits, he is a bit shy and he is an old dad (50 I think) which may be a factor.  I have had no deep talks with him before, I’ve only seen him about 6 or 7 times I think.  So what do you all think? Thanks in advance, — Leonie Lawson Co-Creator of Maia Shea (19/11/96) and Casta Grace (9/8/98) dum vivimus, vivamus (while we live, let us live)

Response:

Question:

Has anyone out there watched the cartoon show called Pokemon?  I just saw my first episode today (my kids are grown, so I don’t usually watch the morning cartoons anymore). The storyline is a young boy, trying to become some sort of ‘master’ Pokemon trainer.  Pokemon are little animals, that they capture in the wild, using some sort of ’storage ball’.   They then train their Pokemon to fight other Pokemon. Sometimes, the Pokemon fights are done in Pokemon Arenas or Pokemon Gyms. Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?  Or at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more animals fight each other?   And to train them to do it? I’ve only seen the one episode, so I might be totally off base, here.  I don’t mean this post to troll, just to incite a little discussion from people who might have seen more episodes, and tell me I’ve got it wrong…I hope I do.

Response:

>Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?  Or >at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more

animals fight each other? I don’t think so, since Pokemon is the most popular video game out there, and since  kids, even little ones, know it’s a game and not founded in reality. The Pokemon characters have no resemblance to any species of actual animal. It’s like saying that a video game about boxing (and there are quite a few out there) is teaching kids to pit humans against one another… This is just my opinion, and I could be wrong, it has happened before…but I think it’s harmless.

Response:

>The Pokemon characters have no resemblance to any species of actual animal. >It’s like saying that a video game about boxing (and there are quite a few >out >there) is teaching kids to pit humans against one another…

Actually, some resemble animals, but vaguely. These "pokemon" are monsters, not animals, and they have special powers. They don’t usually use physical forces, but rather their water skills or something or other. (I myself am not a pokemon fan, but my little sister likes it.) ~*Ally*~

Response:

yeah the pokemon are weird little things, not exactly like real animals. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?  Or >at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more > animals fight each other? > I don’t think so, since Pokemon is the most popular video game out there, and > since  kids, even little ones, know it’s a game and not founded in reality. > The Pokemon characters have no resemblance to any species of actual animal. > It’s like saying that a video game about boxing (and there are quite a few out > there) is teaching kids to pit humans against one another… > This is just my opinion, and I could be wrong, it has happened before…but I > think it’s harmless.

Response:

> Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?  Or > at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more > animals fight each other?   And to train them to do it?

I don’t know about that, but since my friend’s son started collecting the stupid cards, he’s been in all sorts of trouble. From stealing the cards to fighting with other kids over the damn things. My friend does not allow them in the house anymore. Nic http://www.teleport.com/~pitbull – a Pit & a Pug

Response:

I’m something of a fan of the show myself (oh, shut up <G>).  I really don’t think Pokemon would "teach kids to pit fight."  For one thing, the pokemon fight with special magical powers, like lightning, water, fire, etc, not by biting and ripping each other up.  Second, most of the pokemon don’t resemble real animals.  Third, there is no third. Fourth, the pokemon are intelligent, with their own language.  The little critters just don’t resemble real animals in any way. Denna Lasik Bored? Visit Windwolf’s Completely Useless Webpage! Pointless, bandwidth wasting info about me, and pics of my artwork and pets. A great time for the easily amused! http://www.picantes.com/windwolf * Remove references to flourescent pink pseudo-meat before replying.

Response:

Hehehe, I’m like Denna… I like the show!.  My nieces are all big fans and I haven’t notice any change in them except doing a lot more chores so they could earn the cash to buy more pokemon cards.  They know it’s not real, any more real then Sailor Moon and the negaverse was :) And the characters really care about the Pokemon (which are not animals, but rather monsters — the name Pokemon comes from "pocket monsters"). — Danae – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I’m something of a fan of the show myself (oh, shut up <G>).  I really >don’t think Pokemon would "teach kids to pit fight."  For one thing, >the pokemon fight with special magical powers, like lightning, water, >fire, etc, not by biting and ripping each other up.  Second, most of >the pokemon don’t resemble real animals.  Third, there is no third. >Fourth, the pokemon are intelligent, with their own language.  The >little critters just don’t resemble real animals in any way. >Denna Lasik

Response:

The > little critters just don’t resemble real animals in any way.

OH YEAH??? You OBVIOUSLY haven’t seen my cat. She’s a dead ringer for Jigglypuff!! — Christy Visit Dakota, the handsomest mutt inna world! http://members.xoom.com/cool4cats/dakota.html

Response:

>OH YEAH??? >You OBVIOUSLY haven’t seen my cat. She’s a dead ringer for Jigglypuff!! > If Lily is your cat, no she isn’t.  She’s beautiful!  Now, some of > those kittens could make a passable Jigglypuff… ;-) > BTW, Dakota is gorgeous! > Denna Lasik

Lily is a rescue kitty – she has a new home now as do 4 of the 6 kittens (last two are stubborn & don’t wanna go!) Jigglypuff, er, I mean Maris, is a 4 year old Persian, mostly white, shaped like a basketball with legs. Thanks for telling me my pooch is a beaut – that officially makes him Supreme Mondo Grand Champeen Esquire of the ChCK!! I’m so proud. ;P — Christy Visit Dakota, the handsomest mutt inna world! http://members.xoom.com/cool4cats/dakota.html

Response:

>OH YEAH??? >You OBVIOUSLY haven’t seen my cat. She’s a dead ringer for Jigglypuff!!

If Lily is your cat, no she isn’t.  She’s beautiful!  Now, some of those kittens could make a passable Jigglypuff… ;-) BTW, Dakota is gorgeous! Denna Lasik Bored? Visit Windwolf’s Completely Useless Webpage! Pointless, bandwidth wasting info about me, and pics of my artwork and pets. A great time for the easily amused! http://www.picantes.com/windwolf * Remove references to flourescent pink pseudo-meat before replying.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Has anyone out there watched the cartoon show called Pokemon?  I just saw my >first episode today (my kids are grown, so I don’t usually watch the morning >cartoons anymore). >The storyline is a young boy, trying to become some sort of ‘master’ Pokemon >trainer.  Pokemon are little animals, that they capture in the wild, using >some sort of ’storage ball’.   They then train their Pokemon to fight other >Pokemon. >Sometimes, the Pokemon fights are done in Pokemon Arenas or Pokemon Gyms. >Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?  Or >at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more >animals fight each other?   And to train them to do it? >I’ve only seen the one episode, so I might be totally off base, here.  I >don’t mean this post to troll, just to incite a little discussion from >people who might have seen more episodes, and tell me I’ve got it wrong…I >hope I do.

I don’t know.  If you believe that violence on TV, not poor parenting is the cause of the problems of the day, then yes, I guess you could believe that Pokemon could lead to kids fighting animals. But then, if you’re a responsible parent, you know that your kids understand that it’s just a game, that animals of all forms are to be treated with respect, and that stealing cards is something that will get the kid in deep $#!t.  (Which, BTW, the stealing part has led to several problems where I work). I guess if you don’t trust your kids, then yes, you *should* ban the game from your house, because you haven’t been a good enough parent to teach them that respect, and while you’re at it, pick up a parenting class at the local college. ~Emily

Response:

> Has anyone out there watched the cartoon show called Pokemon?  I just saw my > first episode today (my kids are grown, so I don’t usually watch the morning > cartoons anymore).

I watch it semi-regularly, being a ‘toon buff.  From what I can tell, the cartoon is not about fighting Pokemons.  It’s more a message of responsibility for the animals they collect and train.  Yes, some of them do fight, usually with the bad guys (Team Rocket, a bitchy red head and a rather effeminate guy in a half shirt – gotta love cheesy Japanime). There is almost always a moral hidden in the story somewhere.  Basically you have this impetuous and impatient little boy, his older brother, and a sister or girlfriend (I haven’t paid that much attention to the relationships).  They wander around looking for new Pokemons, learning about their differences and learning to respect the wild or rare ones they run into. There is, of course, an obligatory fight/battle scene in every show between the good guys and the bad guys.  This sort of cartoon is built around a very rigid theme. > The storyline is a young boy, trying to become some sort of ‘master’ Pokemon > trainer.  Pokemon are little animals, that they capture in the wild, using > some sort of ’storage ball’.   They then train their Pokemon to fight other > Pokemon.

Not really.  Mostly they just try to capture these things and train them, and often the Pokemons they capture become good friends.  There is a mutual love between Pokemon and their trainers.  The last episode I watched was about how the little boy was angry that this one guy was "Abusing" his Pokemon by making it do things it was not meant to do, but he later learned that the "Abuser’s" Pokemon did what the guy asked out of love and respect that the guy gave his various critters. > Sometimes, the Pokemon fights are done in Pokemon Arenas or Pokemon Gyms. > Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals?

No. Or > at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or more > animals fight each other?

That isn’t the central storyline, so I doubt it.  If anything Pokemon is better than those damn Tamagotchies that were so popular last year.   And to train them to do it? > I’ve only seen the one episode, so I might be totally off base, here. I > don’t mean this post to troll, just to incite a little discussion from > people who might have seen more episodes, and tell me I’ve got it wrong…I > hope I do.

I think the show has merits, though it’s a bit too cheesy to watch all the time.  I can definitely see the appeal to it and probably would have loved the show as a kid.  As it is, I’m faintly amused by it and will watch it if I have nothing better to do on a Sunday morning. Marianne — — http://www.dewlap.com/shiba Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

>Has anyone out there watched the cartoon show called Pokemon?

OK, OK….hoisted on my own petard… I firmly believe that video games and TV programs don’t promote violent behavior in kids who have been well brought up.  My own children were taught very early on that TV is NOT REAL.  (not even the news, most times :}  ) So, I withdraw the observation.  It was knee-jerk on my part, after having seen only one episode, I had nothing to base on. Although,   my son and I are both AVID players of the game called Magic: the Gathering.   This card game was in existence before Pokemon, and is slowly being subsumed by the new game.  (Wizards of the Coast put out both games) So, for that reason,  I don’t much like Pokemon. Thanks for your replies, everyone! Kellie

Response:

My kids watch Pokemon all the time, my son also has a GameBoy and 2 Pokemon games.  (Red and Blue version!!) We also watch the show every day FAITHFULLY!!!)  Pokemon are monsters, they are wild and the object of the game is to catch as many as you can on your adventure to become a Master Pokemon trainer. There are other trainers who will challenge you to fight your Pokemon against theirs.  Your Pokemon will advance to higher levels, and gain more skills the more you fight it.   It’s like the cartoon.  I don’t think it’s any worse than any other cartoon out there.  (Remember PacMan from the 80’s!!)  PacMan was big back then, and Pokemon is really big now.  I seriously doubt the first thing my kids think of is pit fighting animals when they are watching the show!!!  They have their favorites (Nidorino and Chansey!!) and I am partial to Jigglypuff myself !!!  (It’s so cute!!!)  Maureen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Has anyone out there watched the cartoon show called Pokemon?  I just >saw my > first episode today (my kids are grown, so I don’t usually watch the >morning > cartoons anymore). >I watch it semi-regularly, being a ‘toon buff.  From what I can tell, >the cartoon is not about fighting Pokemons.  It’s more a message of >responsibility for the animals they collect and train.  Yes, some of >them do fight, usually with the bad guys (Team Rocket, a bitchy red head >and a rather effeminate guy in a half shirt – gotta love cheesy >Japanime). >There is almost always a moral hidden in the story somewhere.  Basically >you have this impetuous and impatient little boy, his older brother, and >a sister or girlfriend (I haven’t paid that much attention to the >relationships).  They wander around looking for new Pokemons, learning >about their differences and learning to respect the wild or rare ones >they run into. >There is, of course, an obligatory fight/battle scene in every show >between the good guys and the bad guys.  This sort of cartoon is built >around a very rigid theme. > The storyline is a young boy, trying to become some sort of ‘master’ >Pokemon > trainer.  Pokemon are little animals, that they capture in the wild, >using > some sort of ’storage ball’.   They then train their Pokemon to fight >other > Pokemon. >Not really.  Mostly they just try to capture these things and train >them, and often the Pokemons they capture become good friends.  There is >a mutual love between Pokemon and their trainers.  The last episode I >watched was about how the little boy was angry that this one guy was >"Abusing" his Pokemon by making it do things it was not meant to do, but >he later learned that the "Abuser’s" Pokemon did what the guy asked out >of love and respect that the guy gave his various critters. > Sometimes, the Pokemon fights are done in Pokemon Arenas or Pokemon >Gyms. > Does anyone else think this is teaching kids how to pit fight animals? >No. >Or > at least sending the signal that it is OK to enjoy watching two or >more > animals fight each other? >That isn’t the central storyline, so I doubt it.  If anything Pokemon is >better than those damn Tamagotchies that were so popular last year. >  And to train them to do it? > I’ve only seen the one episode, so I might be totally off base, here. >I > don’t mean this post to troll, just to incite a little discussion from > people who might have seen more episodes, and tell me I’ve got it >wrong…I > hope I do. >I think the show has merits, though it’s a bit too cheesy to watch all >the time.  I can definitely see the appeal to it and probably would have >loved the show as a kid.  As it is, I’m faintly amused by it and will >watch it if I have nothing better to do on a Sunday morning. >Marianne >– >– >http://www.dewlap.com/shiba >Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

Question:

I had my baby when I was 40 years old.  How would you like to be 40 and It’s something that just comes to you as more time goes by.  I was very uncomfortable with Maya, 3.5 now, at first and drove my mother nuts calling with questions every 5 minutes….and you know if I’m 43 now that my mom is much older!  She’d tell me…."it’s been a very long time….I don’t remember that"!  All I can tell you is the more time that goes by the more comfortable you’ll be…it’s almost instinctive. You sound like a wonderful and loving mother already to me!  At my age, it’s very feasible to have an older daughter as well, so….scream here or email me if you have any questions at all…I’ll sure try to help! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >    I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to > feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or > anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a > day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not > regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or > over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can > not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she > was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her > to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten >   <forced to snip due to fussy server>

Response:

I am the mother of 3 healthy girls. I didnt do anything right but they are still alive.  Kids are tuff and resilient.   Over protection can be just as bad as underprotection.   Let them grow  they will learn. Rena

Response:

Congratulations!!!! I was in the same situation when my son was born. I had a mother but not much of one (I was a pawn in her life with my dad)Anyway I thought that I was doing everything wrong and had a husband who was very unsupportive  and a mother-in law that felt she was the only one who should raise her Grandson. with the help of a very supportive Dr. I learned that I was a good mother to my son and that by reading books and taking what I read with a grain of salt I would learn the things that I was never taught and to always trust my gut feeling. My Dr. did go beyond the call of duty by calling out of the blue to see how things were going.(he knew my husband and in-laws and knew the situation was a bad one) Trust yourself beyond anyone else and seek the knowledge on your own whether it be here,books,your Dr.or your Mother-In Law. In the end you will know My ex-husband demanded that the house be clean and laundry always(every-day) done. Your husband is a lot more supportive than mine was so the need may not be there but I kept the house picked up and tried to get the laundry done everyday but as far as cleaning went I called a local cleaning service and was surprised to find out that they would come in to my home every other week and dust,vacuum, clean my bathrooms,make beds,and clean my kitchen(no dishes) and the charge was $50 a cleaning I don’t know your financial situation but if you can afford it and if having a clean home is on your priority list check out services in your area. I think that by what you have said you are doing a wonderful job. You will never stop worrying about your child and by showing love you are doing great Keep it up JMHO(I know my situation was different) Kerry-Lynn Noah’s mom

Response:

I think I missed the original poster, but…. In my case, my mother had a VERY abusive father and none of her family knew how to be good parents.  With my daughter, I did what I thought I would have wanted my own mother to do.  When I had questions, I called a cousin who had three kids – the youngest about a year older than mine. My husband’s first words were, I get up at 4 a.m., I am not getting up for the middle of the night feedings.  You can guess how much support I got and am getting from there.  I never hear from his family ’cause they’d rather have my daughter than me and they know I know it, and it’s not going to happen.  They raised my Stepson so have no concept of how to react to someone actually wanting to raise their own child. I did any housework while my daughter napped.  If I felt tired, I’d lay down with her.  If my husband made a comment about the house, I’d tell him to take care of a child and try to do anything with a house.  My daughter is now 20 months, I still can’t do laundry without her trying to help.  Where’s he?  At the computer, as usual. I’m sure this doesn’t help much.  But remember, you only get one go around with your children.  The housework will be there until someone does it. Your child will be there one day and be off to college the next. Cindy

Response:

Sorry about the double posting I just realized Kerry-Lynn Mom to Noah

Response:

Hi, I just wanted to say you are not alone out there and there are people who care and are willing to listen. Maybe this will make you feel better. I am a mother of 4 children ages 5,3,2,10months.I choose to stay home fulltime while my husband works crazy hours.We really cant afford a daycare nor do I want to go that route anyway.I am alone with my kids most of the time,I really dont get out much only when I can find a baby sitter.I have been depressed with myself for a while now and im finally going for counciling and getting medication for it.My life is pretty full with the kids.I worry about there well being all the time,making sure there feeling ok,giving enough love being that there is 4 of them.I have been in your shoes before with my first child. Checking in the middle of the night ,not getting sleep,feeling though as if im not doing enough,etc…That is a normal process and you will get adjusted.Have you had any counciling with this? Are you on any medication such as prozac?I think this is important to talk to someone who has been there before and even still going through it now.It hasnt been to easy for me but,with family support,councilng and medication to take some of the edge off,Im getting through it. If you would like to talk further let me know. Take Care…lol..Lisa

Response:

I myself, used to be a very, very protective mommy. I still am protective, but am a bit more lax. My son is, by choice, going to be an only child, and I have basically been a stay home mommy since he was born. I am now looking for work to help pay bills and give him interaction with other kids. Trust your instincts, and remember, it is OKAY to be protective. You will start to relax a bit. Trust me. I used to be "psycho mom" when it came to my Zackie, now he runs around the house all the time, or should I say runs the house :) . I looked in on him when he was sleeping,and still do, to make sure he is breathing, that is just a mommy thing. You are normal, especially if this is child #1. Sara: wife to Rick, mommy to Zachary (12/9/96)

Response:

What you’re feeling is entirely normal! First of all, it will help you tremendously if you can just let some of the housework go.  Prioritize, and figure out what it is you ABSOLUTELY    have to have clean, and clean that.  With a newborn/young child you’re not going to be able to do everything that you had done B.C…"before child".  If the floor only gets mopped twice a month as opposed to once a week, nobody’s going to die. When my son was that age, I played this terrible game with myself.  "I’m almost asleep, so I’ll just go check him one more time before I drift off…"  This, of course, led to Mommy never sleeping.  I was just sure it was the sheer force of my will that was keeping him alive.  Guess what?  It wasn’t.  It was the sheer force of HIS will. I think that just the fact that you’re worried about being a good mother indicates that you’re already a good mother.  You love your daughter, she loves you.  That is truly the most important thing.  If you can learn to relax a little and stop second-guessing every parenting decision you make, you’ll find that things start to flow more and more easily.  It doesn’t really matter that you didn’t have much baby experience before…you’ve got PRACTICAL experience now.  It doesn’t matter that you weren’t raised with the help of your mother…you had a loving parent that taught you trust and love and understanding.  You’ve got all the tools that you need! Trust your instincts.  Rely on help from your husband.  Hug your baby every chance you get.  And remember…YOU ARE A WONDERFUL MOTHER!!! Amanda

Response:

Oh sweetie!  ****BIG HUG******  You are a good mom.  (tell yourself that 100 times) We all worry about our babies.  That’s just part of the job.  And it’s natural for you to worry even more since you haven’t been around babies and don’t know what’s "normal." (There really isn’t a normal that fits every child.  They are all individuals.)  The house will be clean again one day. Don’t let that bug you.  Ask your hubby if he can help out with some of that.  And don’t feel guilty about doing it.  But let the baby be your first priority now.  My two are 3 yrs and 7 yrs, my house still isn’t clean all the time.  lol  Whenever someone comes to visit that I wasn’t expecting, I always apologize for the mess.  And you know what they all say?  "Hey, you’ve got kids. The house isn’t supposed to be neat as a pin." You are doing a wonderful job.  No one else will be able to love that baby the way you do.  And that you are asking for support only says to me that you want to be the best mom you can be. You have come to a good place to look for that support.  There are a lot of very caring, smart, wonderful people in this group.  Any time you have a question you need answered, just ask away. Take care, Sharon

   I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten worse.  I get up at all hours of the night just to touch her to make sure she is still breathing.  It is almost like all my brain quits working when I think somethig s wrong with her

Response:

I stay at home too, and I’ve noticed that when you are at home you tend to dwell/obsess with things more than if you worked full or part time. Pretend you did work one or more days a week, would you sweat over the details as much? Probably not–you couldn’t because you wouldn’t have the time! So just relax! We’re all pulling for you, and if you’re crazy then we all are. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Oh sweetie!  ****BIG HUG******  You are a good mom.  (tell yourself that 100 > times) > We all worry about our babies.  That’s just part of the job.  And it’s > natural for you to worry even more since you haven’t been around babies and > don’t know what’s "normal." (There really isn’t a normal that fits every > child.  They are all individuals.)  The house will be clean again one day. > Don’t let that bug you.  Ask your hubby if he can help out with some of > that.  And don’t feel guilty about doing it.  But let the baby be your first > priority now.  My two are 3 yrs and 7 yrs, my house still isn’t clean all > the time.  lol  Whenever someone comes to visit that I wasn’t expecting, I > always apologize for the mess.  And you know what they all say?  "Hey, > you’ve got kids. The house isn’t supposed to be neat as a pin." > You are doing a wonderful job.  No one else will be able to love that baby > the way you do.  And that you are asking for support only says to me that > you want to be the best mom you can be. > You have come to a good place to look for that support.  There are a lot of > very caring, smart, wonderful people in this group.  Any time you have a > question you need answered, just ask away. > Take care, > Sharon >    I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to > feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or > anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a > day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not > regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or > over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can > not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she > was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her > to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten > worse.  I get up at all hours of the night just to touch her to make > sure she is still breathing.  It is almost like all my brain quits > working when I think somethig s wrong with her

Response:

Welcome to motherhood!!!!!  I too have a daughter (7 months in a couple of days) but she is my third.  The other two are 11 and 7.  Yes, you will go through these phases.  About your house, messy is okay.  Your child needs your attention more than the laundry.  As long as my beds are made and dishes are done, I’m happy (kind of)  Feel free to e-mail me or just post here if you need to talk.  You are SO normal!!!!!!!

   I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten worse.  I get up at all hours of the night just to touch her to make sure she is still breathing.  It is almost like all my brain quits working when I think somethig s wrong with her.   I know that you cant find moms over the internet but I was sure hoping I could at least find some motherly advice.  I have never really been around children.  I was so excited when I found out I was pregnant.  We had been trying for a couple of years.  I read every book available and went to every parenting class in our area.  I want more than anything to be a good mom.  I want to be the mother I never had.    This is going to sound terrible, but I had never even changed diapers before.  My husband has had to show me everything.   He comes from a large family.  I was raised by the greatest singl dad in the world.  I have learned a lot in the last 7 months but not eneogh.  I am genuinly looking for loving motherly support.  I want to know how to teach her values.  How to love her so she will grow up with confidence.  I see so many neglected children today.  I think it all starts at home.  I’ve never had a mother to teach me so I am going at this mommy thing blindly.  Any advice and loving support no matter how small can help.  Thank you

Response:

I don’t think anyone with young children has a clean house these days – playing and being with your kids is so much more important than a clean and tidy house. As long as everyone is fed, the clothes are clean, and the house clean enough to keep from being infested with roaches, then relax. I don’t think anyone grows up wishing their Mom had spent more time cleaning and less time paying attention to them. Relax, you’re doing a great job. As far as meeting other Moms, you sound like you really need to. Try finding a Mothers support group, there are quite a few around. The top two that I know of are F.E.M.A.L.E. (Formerly Employed Mothers At the Leading Edge) and the Mothers’ Centers(www.motherscenter.org). You could also try meeting other Moms at local Gymboree classes or other Mommy and Me classes. Good Luck Heidi

Response:

First of all **HUGE HUGS**You are already doing a GREAT job!!!! If you weren’t already a great mom then you wouldn’t care so much. Give up on the clean house thing, you’ll only drive yourself mad. Do you and your hubby have clean underwear? Then thats all you need. I am the mother of 2 girls Samantha is 7 and Mackenzie is 5 1/2 months. Even though I have been through it all with Sami, I’m just as paranoid with Mackenzie. I took Mak to the dr when she was about 2 weeks old because she was breathing funny too. You teach her values by the examples that you and your hubby set. If you get to much change back at the register you give it back, if you see someone that’s "different" than you take the time to talk about what makes people different and that just because someone is different doesn’t make them a bad person. NEVER EVER EVER EVER call your child a name ie: stupid, lazy etc. it can really harm a child. Tell her something about her that you really like, ie: she’s smart or funny or has a great sense of humor. Tell her that she did a great job trying something new. And make sure that when you are talking on the phone to another adult that you always tell them how great you think she is. If she hears you talking about her to other people then she will know how much you care about her. And don’t EVER take everything you read in books and magazines to heart ,remember,YOU know your child better than anyone else in the whole world (including your husband). Geez I could go on and on. Please feel free to e-mail me. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >    I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to > feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or > anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a > day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not > regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or > over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can > not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she > was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her > to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten > worse.  I get up at all hours of the night just to touch her to make > sure she is still breathing.  It is almost like all my brain quits > working when I think somethig s wrong with her.   I know that you cant > find moms over the internet but I was sure hoping I could at least find > some motherly advice.  I have never really been around children.  I was > so excited when I found out I was pregnant.  We had been trying for a > couple of years.  I read every book available and went to every > parenting class in our area.  I want more than anything to be a good > mom.  I want to be the mother I never had.    This is going to sound > terrible, but I had never even changed diapers before.  My husband has > had to show me everything.   He comes from a large family.  I was raised > by the greatest singl dad in the world.  I have learned a lot in the > last 7 months but not eneogh.  I am genuinly looking for loving motherly > support.  I want to know how to teach her values.  How to love her so > she will grow up with confidence.  I see so many neglected children > today.  I think it all starts at home.  I’ve never had a mother to teach > me so I am going at this mommy thing blindly.  Any advice and loving > support no matter how small can help.  Thank you

Response:

   I am the new mother of a perfect 7 month old baby.  I am begining to feel like I am loosing my mind.  I cant seem to get my house clean or anything else accomlished  for that matter.  I work for three hours a day to get out of the house.  I chose to stay at home and I do not regret that at all.  I’m not sure if what I am feeling is common or over-reacting.  From the day we brought her home from the hospital I can not stop worring.(She was born with no health problems at all)  When she was almost 2 weeks old I thought she was breathing funny so I rushed her to the doctor.  Of course she was completely normal.  It has only gotten worse.  I get up at all hours of the night just to touch her to make sure she is still breathing.  It is almost like all my brain quits working when I think somethig s wrong with her.   I know that you cant find moms over the internet but I was sure hoping I could at least find some motherly advice.  I have never really been around children.  I was so excited when I found out I was pregnant.  We had been trying for a couple of years.  I read every book available and went to every parenting class in our area.  I want more than anything to be a good mom.  I want to be the mother I never had.    This is going to sound terrible, but I had never even changed diapers before.  My husband has had to show me everything.   He comes from a large family.  I was raised by the greatest singl dad in the world.  I have learned a lot in the last 7 months but not eneogh.  I am genuinly looking for loving motherly support.  I want to know how to teach her values.  How to love her so she will grow up with confidence.  I see so many neglected children today.  I think it all starts at home.  I’ve never had a mother to teach me so I am going at this mommy thing blindly.  Any advice and loving support no matter how small can help.  Thank you

Response:

Question:

: Some lies are : factual (ie did you eat a piece of cake before dinner? Either you did or : you didn’t)  Kids "lie" for a variety of reasons. Some of it is just having fun, and basically storytelling. Sometimes, it’s a game to see what people will buy. Other times, things get more serious, and the child must consider what they say in order to get the most desired response.  Take the cake question for instance- "did you have a piece of cake before dinner?"  If the child came from an abusive/disturbed household, they might say "No" even though they really did. Consider that if they told the truth and said "Yes" the result might be physical assault or other punishment in their birth parent’s house.  Safer in their mind to lie, and hope to get off the hook. As a child like this settles down into a more stable household, they will mostly realize that their needs will be looked after, and they’re not going to get hit. They will no longer need to double guess their adoptive parents to avoid getting hurt.  There’s also the issue of lack of parental role models to know which truth to tell when, and how much of it.

Response:

> I’m more curious as to what you think "lying" is?

Any words you want to apply, if you ask me where I was, and I make up 5 different stories that cannot all be true, most people can agree that a lie has been told. >:  Treatment: >:  Get the child to write down lies told, what they were feeling at the >:  time, and what the consequences were. >That’s impossible. One could say that every time we fail to spill our >guts, we’re "telling a lie"

Truth is not purely invented to please the teller and listener.   (I enjoy good fiction, but …) > This is not to say that the occasional "whopper" should be ignored. Call >the child on it, get to the root of the matter, and if needed, discuss it. >The idea of leadership is to provide the guidance for the youth to make a >better decision next time.

Now you are at my starting point.  This is where the "disease" theory was brought in. Can I take it you haven’t heard of the disease of lying? Any idea which eminent Psychologist or Educator invented the theory? === Thanks for you comments Elaine,

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >  I’m more curious as to what you think "lying" is? Each of us has our own > truths. These truths are never the same from family to family. >  The only way that we can function together is to come to an understanding > about which "truth" to tell who. Family members usually require bigger > doses of someone’s version of truth. Yet if you go too far, you’ll end up > hurting your relative’s feelings if you don’t also learn to keep your big > mouth shut. >  When you’re dealing with a child who grew up learning another adult’s set > of values and interaction, there will always be a gap between your > standards and those of the other parent/s. >  Belive me, you don’t just want the child to be "more truthful". What you > want is for them to adopt your household’s habits of interaction. For > instance- > you don’t especially wish to hear about your spouse’s pornography > collection that the child may have discovered. >  You do want the child to be dependable and to learn to fit in to your > household as gracefully as possible. > That’s impossible. One could say that every time we fail to spill our > guts, we’re "telling a lie". It’s the process of growing up, maturing, > that over time, we learn what to say. We need to learn judgement, and this > doesn’t happen all at one time. Sometimes, the thing left unsaid, or the > white lie, will make the difference between a smoothly running house, and > pure havoc. >  This is not to say that the occasional "whopper" should be ignored. Call > the child on it, get to the root of the matter, and if needed, discuss it. > The idea of leadership is to provide the guidance for the youth to make a > better decision next time.

Elaine, I have to agree with you on this. Just as different families have different views of lying, so do different cultures. What one family may see as "protecting" a child another may see as "lying" (take for example telling a child about a parent’s serious illness). Some lies are factual (ie did you eat a piece of cake before dinner? Either you did or you didn’t) but many more are subjective and are based on the family, culture and emotional environment someone has grown up in. I think you can correct the factual lies much more easily than the subjective ones, and you need to make a difference in the way you treat them.

Response:

>>Premise: >Treatment: >Okay, I don’t get this. How is this treating lying like a disease? I don’t >know any diseases that are treated by writing things down… >This looks more to me like trying to find out the reasons for the lying, and >helping the child see what happens, right? I don’t get the "disease" >comparison at all.

In the presentation of the idea, this was described as similar in some ways to bedwetting, failure to toilet train, or gambling (all are sometimes discussed in these terms)..  Something that the parent and child did not directly cause, and more of the nature of an outside influence to the relationships involved.  The word disease was part of the early discussion and therefore I included it as a likely keyword in isolating the source material.   I am also confused how words like this are considered appropriate, and this is not an exception.  The main reason for asking about where the idea developed is to help understand the intent and effective application of the theory. >Isn’t the reasoning that it would be helpful both to know why the child is >lying and for the child to see possible results of lying?

I agree, from a first look, it seems to be aimed at understanding the effects both good and bad of lying even if you never get to a cause. > In our case the child has offered explanations that range from "I >thought you would be mad" to "It makes me feel like my real Mom". >It sounds to me like both of these could easily be true.

Yes, and in many cases, we cannot be sure which of the several offered explanations is closest to "true", even though they are contradictory. So far, the child’s skill at lying is not high enough to create the most believable explanation first and stick to it. >My concern, based in limited experience with teen and adult habitual >liers is that since they are good enough at it to get away with it >most of the time, the wrong conclusion can be reached.  This would >equip the child to become an excellent lier. >Well, I think that no matter what strategy you decide to use, this would be >a problem. An older child or teenager from a difficult background (as most >older adopted children are) has probably learned to lie very well in order >to survive and cope with the stresses of his or her life. So you are >inevitably going to miss lots of the lies.

I agree, and an improperly applied piece of psychotherapy can do more damage than good in such a situation.   I know one adult (between 30 and 50)  who lies so well that to do half of what he believes (convinces himself) to be true he would have to be about 90 years old.  Any one of his stories is so good people take him into their homes and provide most of what he needs.  With this counter-example, I want to avoid duplicating his skill level. Thank you for your reply  Teresa

Response:

: Premise: : In the context of an older child adoption, lying should be handled : like a disease, rather than a behavioral problem or a reaction to some : parent stimulus.    I’m more curious as to what you think "lying" is? Each of us has our own truths. These truths are never the same from family to family.  The only way that we can function together is to come to an understanding about which "truth" to tell who. Family members usually require bigger doses of someone’s version of truth. Yet if you go too far, you’ll end up hurting your relative’s feelings if you don’t also learn to keep your big mouth shut.  When you’re dealing with a child who grew up learning another adult’s set of values and interaction, there will always be a gap between your standards and those of the other parent/s.  Belive me, you don’t just want the child to be "more truthful". What you want is for them to adopt your household’s habits of interaction. For instance- you don’t especially wish to hear about your spouse’s pornography collection that the child may have discovered.  You do want the child to be dependable and to learn to fit in to your household as gracefully as possible. : Treatment: : Get the child to write down lies told, what they were feeling at the : time, and what the consequences were. That’s impossible. One could say that every time we fail to spill our guts, we’re "telling a lie". It’s the process of growing up, maturing, that over time, we learn what to say. We need to learn judgement, and this doesn’t happen all at one time. Sometimes, the thing left unsaid, or the white lie, will make the difference between a smoothly running house, and pure havoc.  This is not to say that the occasional "whopper" should be ignored. Call the child on it, get to the root of the matter, and if needed, discuss it. The idea of leadership is to provide the guidance for the youth to make a better decision next time.   Of course you have to catch the : lie, call them on it, and insist they write this down the first few : times.  When no lies are detected for about 6 months, then the cure is : probably complete. : —- : This interesting premise was given to us by someone recently, and I : would like to ask if anyone here has an idea of the "source" works : that might give an insight of the framework from which it comes.  For : instance I have found the following sources: : —  "Positive Discipline" comes from books of that title by Dr. Jane : Nelson (1986). : —  Areas of Acceptance and Nonacceptance seem to come from Dr. Thomas : Gordon’s books on Parent Effectiveness Training (1970).  This was : still recommended material in Foster/Adopt Parenting classes in the : mid-1990’s. : — The value of fairy tales and nursery rhymes (un-sweetened) comes at : least partly from Dr. Bruno Bettelheim’s The Uses of Enchantment : (1989).  He also wrote about people raised in the Israeli Kabutz in : 1969. : — Toughlove is a support network formed by Phyllis and David York. : Started in the 1970’s. : — Dr. Benjamin  Spock’s book on Child Care (1957). : For me this seems to have some interesting possibilities, but I am : having to put guesses into the "reasoning" why it should work.  That : is always risky, and may lead to not implementing the right side : supports to make the treatment effective. : The premise seems to be that lyinig in older child adoptions is not : uncommon or directly something learned from the current parents.  It : could  possibly not be directly from the original parents or foster : homes either.  The perspectives of P.E.T., or Positive Discipline may : not apply because you don’t have any chance to "remember" doing : something which caused the reaction and whatever the child says may be : a lie to divert away from a painful or unconcious memory. :  In our case the child has offered explanations that range from "I : thought you would be mad" to "It makes me feel like my real Mom". : The goal is to help the child conclude that lying is not an effective : strategy. : My concern, based in limited experience with teen and adult habitual : liers is that since they are good enough at it to get away with it : most of the time, the wrong conclusion can be reached.  This would : equip the child to become an excellent lier.

Response:

>Premise: >In the context of an older child adoption, lying should be handled >like a disease, rather than a behavioral problem or a reaction to some >parent stimulus. >Treatment: >Get the child to write down lies told, what they were feeling at the >time, and what the consequences were.  Of course you have to catch the >lie, call them on it, and insist they write this down the first few >times.  When no lies are detected for about 6 months, then the cure is >probably complete.

Okay, I don’t get this. How is this treating lying like a disease? I don’t know any diseases that are treated by writing things down… This looks more to me like trying to find out the reasons for the lying, and helping the child see what happens, right? I don’t get the "disease" comparison at all. (snipped stuff on sources) >For me this seems to have some interesting possibilities, but I am >having to put guesses into the "reasoning" why it should work.  That >is always risky, and may lead to not implementing the right side >supports to make the treatment effective.

Isn’t the reasoning that it would be helpful both to know why the child is lying and for the child to see possible results of lying? >The premise seems to be that lyinig in older child adoptions is not >uncommon or directly something learned from the current parents.  It >could  possibly not be directly from the original parents or foster >homes either.  The perspectives of P.E.T., or Positive Discipline may >not apply because you don’t have any chance to "remember" doing >something which caused the reaction and whatever the child says may be >a lie to divert away from a painful or unconcious memory.

This makes some sense to me. I can see that older children who have been adopted may have all kinds of reasons for lying. They may have seen their birth parents tell lots of lies, they may have learned to lie to escape severe punishments, they may have learned to lie to themselves to erase painful memories. > In our case the child has offered explanations that range from "I >thought you would be mad" to "It makes me feel like my real Mom".

It sounds to me like both of these could easily be true. >The goal is to help the child conclude that lying is not an effective >strategy. >My concern, based in limited experience with teen and adult habitual >liers is that since they are good enough at it to get away with it >most of the time, the wrong conclusion can be reached.  This would >equip the child to become an excellent lier.

Well, I think that no matter what strategy you decide to use, this would be a problem. An older child or teenager from a difficult background (as most older adopted children are) has probably learned to lie very well in order to survive and cope with the stresses of his or her life. So you are inevitably going to miss lots of the lies. Teresa

Response:

Premise: In the context of an older child adoption, lying should be handled like a disease, rather than a behavioral problem or a reaction to some parent stimulus.   Treatment: Get the child to write down lies told, what they were feeling at the time, and what the consequences were.  Of course you have to catch the lie, call them on it, and insist they write this down the first few times.  When no lies are detected for about 6 months, then the cure is probably complete. —- This interesting premise was given to us by someone recently, and I would like to ask if anyone here has an idea of the "source" works that might give an insight of the framework from which it comes.  For instance I have found the following sources: —  "Positive Discipline" comes from books of that title by Dr. Jane Nelson (1986). —  Areas of Acceptance and Nonacceptance seem to come from Dr. Thomas Gordon’s books on Parent Effectiveness Training (1970).  This was still recommended material in Foster/Adopt Parenting classes in the mid-1990’s. — The value of fairy tales and nursery rhymes (un-sweetened) comes at least partly from Dr. Bruno Bettelheim’s The Uses of Enchantment (1989).  He also wrote about people raised in the Israeli Kabutz in 1969. — Toughlove is a support network formed by Phyllis and David York. Started in the 1970’s. — Dr. Benjamin  Spock’s book on Child Care (1957). For me this seems to have some interesting possibilities, but I am having to put guesses into the "reasoning" why it should work.  That is always risky, and may lead to not implementing the right side supports to make the treatment effective. The premise seems to be that lyinig in older child adoptions is not uncommon or directly something learned from the current parents.  It could  possibly not be directly from the original parents or foster homes either.  The perspectives of P.E.T., or Positive Discipline may not apply because you don’t have any chance to "remember" doing something which caused the reaction and whatever the child says may be a lie to divert away from a painful or unconcious memory.  In our case the child has offered explanations that range from "I thought you would be mad" to "It makes me feel like my real Mom". The goal is to help the child conclude that lying is not an effective strategy. My concern, based in limited experience with teen and adult habitual liers is that since they are good enough at it to get away with it most of the time, the wrong conclusion can be reached.  This would equip the child to become an excellent lier.

Response:

Question:

> a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit > her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? > — > As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 > Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here > Mark Panitz

Have you seen this scene repeated times?  By ‘hit’ do you mean spank on the behind or do you mean a whack on the head with a broomstick? (or in between).  It is difficult to ascertain whether a calm talk over tea with the woman or a call to CPS is in order.  A good rule of thumb is, if the physical abuse leaves a mark, or if the behavior would be a crime if done to a dog, then it is illegal.   Unfortunately, most districts still do not consider spanking on the bottom child abuse.  Violence of any kind towards a child is unacceptable, IMHO.  Verbal abuse can often hurt the most.  But, once CPS is called, alot of $h!t can go down.  Is being put in a foster home the best for the daughter?  Or would it make her life worse?  This is a very hard question you ask.  I would think very hard on it, if I were you.  If it is spanking, maybe a talk with the woman would work wonders, who knows? Good luck, Suzy

Response:

a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? — As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here Mark Panitz          

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit > her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? > — > As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 > Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here > Mark Panitz >Have you seen this scene repeated times?  By ‘hit’ do you mean spank on the >behind or do you mean a whack on the head with a broomstick? (or in between). >It >is difficult to ascertain whether a calm talk over tea with the woman or a >call >to CPS is in order.  A good rule of thumb is, if the physical abuse leaves a >mark, or if the behavior would be a crime if done to a dog, then it is >illegal.   >Unfortunately, most districts still do not consider spanking on the bottom >child >abuse.  Violence of any kind towards a child is unacceptable, IMHO.  Verbal >abuse >can often hurt the most.  But, once CPS is called, alot of $h!t can go down. >Is >being put in a foster home the best for the daughter?  Or would it make her >life >worse?  This is a very hard question you ask.  I would think very hard on it, >if >I were you.  If it is spanking, maybe a talk with the woman would work >wonders, >who knows? >Good luck, >Suzy

You are right, these are very serious charges to make and one would definately want to make sure first. I too, do not believe in any physical punishments of any kind for children at all. There are so many other ways to effectively punish and teach children. Besides, I was always afraid that if I smacked my kids, they’d grow up and smack me back! lol!!!!!!! Lizzanne

Response:

> You are right, these are very serious charges to make and one would definately > want to make sure first. > I too, do not believe in any physical punishments of any kind for children at > all. There are so many other ways to effectively punish and teach children. > Besides, I was always afraid that if I smacked my kids, they’d grow up and > smack me back! lol!!!!!!! > Lizzanne

Probably two of the worst punishments my children get are a loooooong talk on how they acted incorrectly and how they can act differently next time, and standing in the corner in a time out.  They are very active children, and to have to sit still for 5 minutes is very hard for them.   This last I mostly use when the child needs time alone to calm down.   Spanking seems more of a retaliation reaction in the heat of the moment. I think it more often than not breeds resentment and a feeling of being a ‘bad person’ than any teaching.   **JMHO** Suzy

Response:

>Probably two of the worst punishments my children get are a loooooong >talk on how they acted incorrectly and how they can act differently next >time, and standing in the corner in a time out.  They are very active >children, and to have to sit still for 5 minutes is very hard for them.   >This last I mostly use when the child needs time alone to calm down.   >Spanking seems more of a retaliation reaction in the heat of the moment. >I think it more often than not breeds resentment and a feeling of being a >’bad person’ than any teaching.   >**JMHO** >Suzy

I agree that time-outs are extremely effective for little ones. I only use the looooooooooong talk for extreme offenses, and my children have many times over the years asked me, "Why are you so wierd? Why can’t you just spank or smack us like other moms do? " This comment,as well as the results of my looooooong talks, lets me know that one of MY talks IS to be dreaded and avoided! (this method also works equally well with misbehaving husbands!) Lizzanne

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Probably two of the worst punishments my children get are a loooooong >talk on how they acted incorrectly and how they can act differently next >time, and standing in the corner in a time out.  They are very active >children, and to have to sit still for 5 minutes is very hard for them. >This last I mostly use when the child needs time alone to calm down. >Spanking seems more of a retaliation reaction in the heat of the moment. >I think it more often than not breeds resentment and a feeling of being a >’bad person’ than any teaching. >**JMHO** >Suzy > I agree that time-outs are extremely effective for little ones. I only use the > looooooooooong talk for extreme offenses, and my children have many times over > the years asked me, "Why are you so wierd? Why can’t you just spank or smack us > like other moms do? " > This comment,as well as the results of my looooooong talks, lets me know that > one of MY talks IS to be dreaded and avoided! > (this method also works equally well with misbehaving husbands!) > Lizzanne

Yes, looong talks work well.  I talk about how they could have handled the situation differently, what shouldthey do next time, how they can make the hurt party feel better, etc.  I prefer to talk until I see at least a little remorse, this tells me my talk is working.  I think they find the standing still part hard, the boring talking hard, and especially the kiss and make up part hard.  But if I separate two warring brothers, give them both a talk, and make them kiss and hug and say sorry, it all inevitably ends up in giggles and laughter, and ‘let’s go play!’ feelings.  I hope I am raising my children well.  I guess I’ll find out in 25 years…  LOL!!! Suzy

Response:

I don’t know if you are legally required, but you may be morally required to report it… OTOH, a very effective way to get parents to talk about the stress they are under is to go over (not in the middle of a crisis) and say to her- "Say, I’ve noticed your little one is quite a handful ( true or not, she evidently believes this). Let me know if I can give you a little break once in a while, okay?"  Listen to this mom.  Chances are, she really doesn’t want to be mean, but she may not have a lot of emotional or financial resources, or maybe she’s just really stressed.  Once you establish some rapport with her, find out if there are any support groups around town, such as Parents Anonymous or even a parenting class, and casually mention you heard about it. I know this sounds like a lot of work, but I believe if we all as neighbors can offer support when it’s needed, many CPS interventions can be avoided. HTH, Natalie – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit >her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? >– >As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 >Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here >Mark Panitz

Response:

I am not as to your legal obligation – it probably depens upon the state that you live in, but as a concerned parent who obviously sees it as something more than normal punishment (or you would most likely not be asking this question..) you probably feel some senseof personal obligation… Many states have Anonymous hotlines which you can call and report suspected abuse, I know in the state that I live in there is one, you can also report it non-anonymously through your local Child Protective Services — they will be listed in the telephone book. (They should also have the number for anonymous hot-line). Please do not feel guilty about reporting this, you obviously are concerned about the discipline you are witnessing – It is not your responsibility to decipher whether it is acceptable or not.  Child Services are trained to distinguish between what is abuse and what is an acceptable form of discipline – that is their job.  I know I will probably get a number of response from people who say to MYOB, but as an advocate for child rights I know too well that if the parent is displaying such behavior in public, what may be going on in private may be much worse.  I know it is an inconvenience to the parents, espcially if there is no abuse – But what if there is — Too many children suffer, and even die from abuse in this country, abuse that could be prevented…parents can be helped to alter their behavior, be taught better parenting skills, removal from the home is the last option – used only after everything else has been tried… Sorry for the long rant, but I see this as a very serious issue. Mark, I hope I gave you some useful information – you can always call Child Protective Services and explain the situation – that is what they are there for. Carrie – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit >her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? >– >As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 >Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here >Mark Panitz

Response:

After my long rant I read this message, and wanted to add that I do agree with this — If you know the neighbor and feel comfortable approaching her you should do this, explain your concerns and offer to help (i.e. take the kids off her hands for a while, suggest parenting classes, etc.) It really depends on the situation… Carrie – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I don’t know if you are legally required, but you may be morally required to >report it… OTOH, a very effective way to get parents to talk about the >stress they are under is to go over (not in the middle of a crisis) and say >to her- "Say, I’ve noticed your little one is quite a handful ( true or not, >she evidently believes this). Let me know if I can give you a little break >once in a while, okay?"  Listen to this mom.  Chances are, she really >doesn’t want to be mean, but she may not have a lot of emotional or >financial resources, or maybe she’s just really stressed.  Once you >establish some rapport with her, find out if there are any support groups >around town, such as Parents Anonymous or even a parenting class, and >casually mention you heard about it. >I know this sounds like a lot of work, but I believe if we all as neighbors >can offer support when it’s needed, many CPS interventions can be avoided. >HTH, >Natalie >a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit >her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? >– >As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 >Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here >Mark Panitz

Response:

>  I hope I am raising my children well.  I guess I’ll >find out in 25 years…  LOL!!! >Suzy

I hope I am too, I think most good parents worry about this quite a bit. I know that I do. As to your statement about "finding out in 25 years", though, I really don’t know. I have seen over the years many, many parents who raised their kids "right", and all the kids the same way, only to have some and/or all turn out horribly. I’ve also seen parents who have raised their kids horribly bad, and yet the children turned out to be perfectly model citizens, with good values and morals. It also always amazes me when I see parents who raise their children all exactly the same way, (be it good OR bad) and SOME of the kids (or one) turn out one way while the others don’t. I think honestly that all good parents simply try their level best to do what’s right, but yet that is NOT always a good indication of how they will turn out. I have sat many times grieving with parents who are close friends or relatives, and who were exemplary parents, over how their kids turned out. I’ve also known some horrible parents who are totally clueless as to why their kids turned out so good. I am of the thought that parenting is really just a crap shoot. You roll the dice to the best of your ability and what comes up, comes up. (which is not to say we shouldn’t try our best anyway) I only say this in an attempt to allieviate some parents future guilt trips somewhat, because there are ALOT of good parents out there grieving over such things, and that seems real sad to me. I hope you get what I’m trying to say. I doubt if I worded it very well. I tend to ramble sometimes, sorry. Lizzanne

Response:

 I have seen over the years many, many parents who raised their kids >"right", and all the kids the same way, only to have some and/or all turn out >horribly. I’ve also seen parents who have raised their kids horribly bad, and >yet the children turned out to be perfectly model citizens, with good values >and morals. It also always amazes me when I see parents who raise their >children all exactly the same way, (be it good OR bad) and SOME of the kids (or >one) turn out one way while the others don’t.

I have to disagree with you here. I’ve snipped the part where you say parenting is a "crap shoot" and that you don’t really have much influence on how children turn out. I think the key is that children are all individuals, and they are all born different. When somebody says they raised their children all exactly the same way, I’m not surprised that some turned out fine and some didn’t. Doing things the same for every child probably means that it was wrong for some children. A huge part of being a parent, IMHO, is recognizing your child’s uniqueness and trying to meet his or her individual needs. I think the reason that some parents who seem to be "horrible" (and I’m not sure what your definition of horrible parents is) is that some children have very easy-going, resilient personalities. They manage despite the poor parenting. Even then, I think there is a cost to those children – they may not grow up to be criminals, but they may suffer from depression or have other problems. And I think parents who seem to be "good" parents, who are sincerely trying to raise their children well, may not be aware of their children’s needs and so don’t respond to them. Teresa

Response:

>a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit >her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? >– >As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 >Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here >Mark Panitz          

I hate to post so soon after being called a "troll", but it is important to be aware that you are making a very serious charge and that the CPS group in your area may be over-worked and under-staffed. I recently had the privilege of seeing this first hand, so PLEASE consider some of the possibilities first. The legal obligation is dependent on the state, county, and city where you live, but a moral obligation does exist (IMHO) if you think the child is being harmed. 1- First see if you feel comfortable talking to the mother directly and offering whatever understanding you can bring.  This can be done without threatening legal consequences.  You can always make a formal report if the discussion turns out badly or the behavior continues. 2- If you are uncomfortable, but do not know of immediate danger, consider the church leaders or school teachers for the child.  They can take the details and move forward without using your name directly. 3- If you feel there is immediate danger to the child (or  you for getting involved), make a complaint to the Police so they can start the process.  They are equiped in many places to handle abuse and bring in the right level of support from social services.  They can act within minutes to remove the child from that home if they see a real danger. 4- If you think that the parent (s) might directly endanger you or your family if they ever figure out that you called, then use an anonymous tip and don’t give any details.  Just the neighbor’s family name, location and the words "child abuse" should be enough.  To really make it anonymous, don’t use your home phone to make that call. It is easiest to make an anonymous call, then pretend you didn’t see anything.  It is probably most effective to directly have the discussion and participate in offering the help needed. — Don

Response:

I didn’t read the original post, but I do want to caution that if you have observed this only once (and it was just yelling and A hit) then you should be VERY careful.  In some areas, the way they handle things like this is go in and take the child out of the situation and THEN evaluate.  If this is just an instance of a mother losing her patience and not really abuse, then it would do worse damage to the child by having her removed from the home for no legitimate reason. If you have seen this happen MANY times and/or you have seen bruises on the girl that couldn’t be explained, then maybe you SHOULD report it. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->a neighboor I have seen is beating (yelling at her child and hit >her -should i report this? or not and who do I call? >– >As Per US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5,Subchapter II 227 >Unsolicited [JUNK MAIL] commercial advertising is NOT Welcome here >Mark Panitz > I hate to post so soon after being called a "troll", but it is > important to be aware that you are making a very serious charge and > that the CPS group in your area may be over-worked and under-staffed. > I recently had the privilege of seeing this first hand, so PLEASE > consider some of the possibilities first. > The legal obligation is dependent on the state, county, and city where > you live, but a moral obligation does exist (IMHO) if you think the > child is being harmed. > 1- First see if you feel comfortable talking to the mother directly > and offering whatever understanding you can bring.  This can be done > without threatening legal consequences.  You can always make a formal > report if the discussion turns out badly or the behavior continues. > 2- If you are uncomfortable, but do not know of immediate danger, > consider the church leaders or school teachers for the child.  They > can take the details and move forward without using your name > directly. > 3- If you feel there is immediate danger to the child (or  you for > getting involved), make a complaint to the Police so they can start > the process.  They are equiped in many places to handle abuse and > bring in the right level of support from social services.  They can > act within minutes to remove the child from that home if they see a > real danger. > 4- If you think that the parent (s) might directly endanger you or > your family if they ever figure out that you called, then use an > anonymous tip and don’t give any details.  Just the neighbor’s family > name, location and the words "child abuse" should be enough.  To > really make it anonymous, don’t use your home phone to make that call. > It is easiest to make an anonymous call, then pretend you didn’t see > anything.  It is probably most effective to directly have the > discussion and participate in offering the help needed. > — Don

Response:

Question:

here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons. my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door.   when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle.   last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and shuts the door. last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that night. any advice would be welcome!

Response:

I dont know what size there bed is but I got my daughter her twin bed/bunk beds at that time. My husband was also very intolerant of not getting sleep and I did just what you said you would do I took preference of Chiara over him. I began to go sleep in her bed .After a while she became more comfortable in it and goes to it herself when she becomes tired. A child that age, atleast most Ive heard of, want to be by thier mommy to sleep. I would just climb in her bed with her untill they enjoy sleeping in it b themselves, that is if life permits. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also > have a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying > "oh, but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 > months, he has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have > their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully > taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as > they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i > gotta work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at > the top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO > SLEEP!!!!"  and shuts the door. > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean > time, marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly > crying and lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered > herself up and falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move > a little to make room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little > where she began to "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 > minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down completely when my husband, > once again, says "ok.. that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while > she’s screaming now for "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells > her to cover up and shut up and go back to sleep.  i can hear her > crying  for me for about an hour. > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a > kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where > i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next > to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather > than waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM > at them, i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be > screamed at that night. > any advice would be welcome!

Response:

 Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> This is a multi-part message in MIME format. > Content-Type: text/plain; >    charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > shuts the door. > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > night. > any advice would be welcome! > Content-Type: text/html; >    charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD W3 HTML//EN"> > <HTML> > <HEAD> > <META content=3Dtext/html;charset=3Diso-8859-1 = > http-equiv=3DContent-Type> > <META content=3D’"MSHTML 4.72.3110.7"’ name=3DGENERATOR> > </HEAD> > <BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>here’s my problem and i hope someone = > can=20 > help.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>I married my husband and had twin = > girls. both=20 > are 2.5 now.&nbsp; i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>my husband, at the beginning used to = > bring the=20 > twins to bed saying &quot;oh, but they’re so cute&quot;.&nbsp; in the = > last 5=20 > months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the = > twins=20 > when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution = > is&nbsp;=20 > forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the = > door.&nbsp; </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had = > much sleep=20 > as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband = > would=20 > complaint &quot;jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i = > gotta=20 > work in the morning!&quot; so i’d get up and give them a bottle.&nbsp;=20 > </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last few weeks, he would say &quot;ashley/marissa = > come in=20 > here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying&quot;) = > and=20 > they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when = > they toss=20 > and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed = > forcefully and=20 > put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top = > of his=20 > lunge &quot;cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!&quot;&nbsp; = > and=20 > shuts the door.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of = > the=20 > twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang = > on to me=20 > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.&nbsp; in the mean = > time,=20 > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down=20 > on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling = > back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for = > marissa=20 > and that just upset ashely a little where she began to &quot;whine&quot; = > (this=20 > took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down = > completely when my husband, once again, says &quot;ok.. that’s it&quot; = > and=20 > YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for &quot;mama&quot; = > and puts=20 > her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; i can hear her crying&nbsp; for me for about an = > hour.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>i am at wits end. on one hand, he = > complaints=20 > when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making = > them=20 > upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!&nbsp; = > there were=20 > nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping = > soundly=20 > next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather = > than=20 > waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM&nbsp; = > at them,=20 > i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at = > that=20 > night.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>any advice would be welcome!</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV>&nbsp;</DIV></BODY></HTML>

– Elaine Gallegos

Response:

>There is nothing "normal" about this behavior. Screaming at *anyone* is >always unacceptable, but especially in the case of small children. If you >feel strongly enough about this to post, I think you need to re-evaluate >your situation and decide what your next move should be. I suggest your >husband seek counseling. If he refuses, then being alone might be best >for best, both for your children and for you. Good Luck! >– >Zombiie – Kail (7/16/97) >reply to: pyaray at newsguy dot com

I agree 100%.  There is NOTHING normal about this behavior and being alone with your kids is so much better for all of you than being with someone abusive.  If you stay with a man who mistreats and abuses you and your kids, your kids will grow to resent you.  If you leave him and make a better life for all of you, your kids will thank you someday.  They will learn that abuse is not acceptable and they will be better people for it. Dawn (Taylor and Mackenzie’s mom)

Response:

    here’s my problem and i hope someone can help.     >. his solution is  forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and >shuts the door.       No one has mentioned getting a bolt so they can’t come in. They won’t like it, but they will learn. Obviously the mother has to stay with them till they sleep on their own if the room is locked, as they can’t be wandering around at night. This is actually a form of discipline and limit-setting.     I don’t think I’d do it, but I would WANT to scream at them. The point is to set the house up so that the situation can’t happen, i.e., locked room for dad, with earplugs for him, too, and prescription sleeping pills if necessary. Also, why are they so active at night, at this age?? By now, they are probably as neurotic as h*ll, which may be why. But, if they are getting day naps, the  naps should be shortened or stopped. They should be kept physically active a great part of the day. Unfortunately, the behavior problems may now have been made permanent because of the abuse they have suffered.     The twins have been taught a lack of discipline and self-care by an idiotic parent, and haven’t learned to get themselves to sleep because they WERE coddled. The part that is really unfortunate is that they are now being penalized for doing what they were taught. They may now not sleep well for many years. Probably professional counseling will be needed.     If there are 5 bedrooms in the house, this all should be a non-issue. Let the dolt sleep in his bed. Lock him in. Keep the twins away in the farthest room. Get them out of bed early. Offer them rewards for changing their behaviour, wear them out all day.Give them hot milk before bed and read them a story or two in bed. Make it clear to them, firmly, that they are to stay IN THEIR beds at night. Instead of the psychological stuff, solve the problem in terms of making them VERY tired at night.     What could have been relatively easy has now been turned into a monstrous problem due to a combination both excessive leniency and excessive harshness. It’s too bad.     Yes, I DO have 2 kids. One slept through the night immediately, to the point where feeding was being missed. The other did it in 3 months. No abuse. The baby would scream. I’d go to his/her crib and pat him/her for a few minutes, NEVER taking baby out. Then, I’d leave. The screaming might begin again, but I would not go  back. It was normally over in 10-15 minutes. Obviously this wasn’t done if the baby might be sick, wet, etc. They never slept with us, except occasionally, and it was made clear to them that this was a huge exception to their normal routine. They have lots of stuffed animals, "stufties" as they call them, to get them through nighttime. They read in bed. Their beds have been made very desirable places, and this helps.     Teaching infants and toddlers separation and self-care skills is very difficult and slow, and now that the whole thing has been bungled so badly, it’s probably best to get professional help for all.     For the mother’s sanity, this had better begin soon, before a crying infant is added to the equation.     Meerkat

Response:

I don’t mean to be blunt but it sounds to me as if you would be better off without him.  It’s only a matter of time before he hurts your kids or you or both.  No one has the right to keep a mom from her crying baby.  He is controlling you and you’re letting him.  I say find help with friends, church, family, etc and take your kids to a better environment. Dawn (Taylor and Mackenzie’s mom)

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->thank you for your message. >he feels that what he’s doing is "correct" and has gotten out of hand. if i go >to them and lays down with them he has a fit also… >there are times where i wished to be a single parent raising 4 babies and one >coming than to continue to allow my children to be yelled and screamed at by >this maniac. and yes, i wouldn’t sleep very soundly either! >he thinks his behavior is normal.  My other two boys are going thru their >preteen and teen years and his reply is "well, look at the way your other kids >turned out" as if they are mass murderers and that i do not know how to raise >or protect my children :( > : here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > : I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > : a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > : my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > : but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > : has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > : tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > : them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > Tantrums, whining, and "upsets" are normal, if undesirable, behavior for > 2.5 year olds. IMO, an adult regularly ‘yelling and screaming’ AT 2.5 year > olds is neither normal nor acceptable. > : when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > : wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > : complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > : work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > : last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > : middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > : the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > : turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > : and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > : top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > : shuts the door. > The way I see it, the poor kids are in a no-win situation. Any waking up > results in moving them to your bed, where what seems to be normal > tossing and turning leads to being screamed at and manhandled by your > husband. Furthermore, I bet that the screaming and arm-yanking > *reinforces* their restless sleep. I certainly wouldn’t sleep soundly if > I was worried about some maniac yelling at me in the middle of the night! > : last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > : crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > : dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > : marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > : lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > : falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > : room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > : "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > : exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > : that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > : "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > : and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > : i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > : up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > : i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > : wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > : and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > : them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > : leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > : night. > I am usually a strong proponent of having parents share ‘getting up’ > duty as much as possible, but in this case you need to protect them from > his abuse. I recommend leaving them in their room and going to sleep > with them if necessary. > You clearly understand that your husband’s behavior is *way* out of hand > and contributing to the problem. Can’t you talk to him and explain that > his actions are making things worse? He also needs to understand that > screaming at and manhandling toddlers in this way is inappropriate, > unacceptable, and just plain abusive, IMO. > Your husband could also benefit from some parenting or anger management > classes. Maybe your pediatrician or local CPS office could recommend a > course that would help. > Laura Uerling

Response:

i suppose that my relationship with my husband is also strained in other areas of our relationship.. financial always is on the top of the list… then it’s the "boys".  He was divorced 14 years and lived alone when we married so having a "teenage" child to him was visits every so often to his ex’s. we are also expecting another baby in january *sighs*.. > Is your relationship with your husband strained in other ways or is this the > main problem in your lives?  Is he abusive to you also?  I wish I could say > something to make it better but the only feeling I get is for you to get > your children and yourself away from him!! > Lorraine > Mother of Maxwell & Charlotte (2 yrs) & Madeline (3 mnths) > P.S. for specific twin advice are you aware that there is a ng called > alt.parenting.twins-triplets ?

Response:

I don’t really know what to say about all this.  I’ve read all the previous posts that have been sent to you.  My first concern is for the safety of the children.  Forcefully yanking them out of the bed could result in terrible injury.  That’s abuse no if’s, and’s or but’s about it.  That’s not a good environment for your children.  Yelling & screaming at them the way you described is also a form of abuse.  I can understand losing him losing his temper; but he’s stepped way over the boundaries.  He doesn’t think he is doing anything wrong and that’s very dangerous.  If he doesn’t think there is anything wrong with yanking them out of bed and yelling at them to stop crying then he may not think it’s wrong to put a pillow over the child’s face to quieten it.  I wouldn’t wait for that to happen.  If he doesn’t want to seek help then it’s up to you to seek safety for your children.  I know it would be hard to raise toddler twins & two teen/preteen children; but I would much rather have the task of raising them myself than feeling the guilt later if his anger got out of control and he injured one of the children.  That’s just my opinion.  But, please think about the safety of your children.  That’s the most important thing. Lisa Mom to Kelsey (2.5)     here’s my problem and i hope someone can help.     I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons.     my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door.     when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle.     last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and shuts the door.     last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour.     i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that night.     any advice would be welcome!

Response:

i’m just waiting for her to get her arm yanked out of the socket at this point in time… :( yes, his behavior is out of line and he can’t see it. he thinks he is almightly and cannot do no wrong. that he is the normal one and i’m the one that’s not normal. that i "coddle" my kids. that instead of "screaming back at them to "stop it!!!!"" that i would try to distract them to get them out of the whine or tantrum mode they are in. and by holding them to comfort them in middle of the night is unnormal for a mother and that i’m only encouraging them to behave this way. i cannot win. if i give in to them, i hurt becuz i know my children is crying for me and needs me and is alone in the room after being yanked out of bed and tossed back into their bed and being screamed at. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he >doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of >refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he >sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that >refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in >some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They >cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and >it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get >blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must >respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure. > This woman’s husband has gone WAY over the line of "grumpy".  I do NOT > agree that this man’s violent behavior is a "simple" matter that is > getting "blown out of proportion".  He needs anger management > intervention ASAP before he injures those babies (or worse).

Response:

unfortunately, he thinks he’s the one that’s acting normal and is raising these children the ‘RIGHT" way! :(  by telling him that he needs to go to a parenting class or even suggesting that he needs to control this behavior would be to say he’s "unnormal" and geeze, that just wouldn’t do :( – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Uh, we’re *all* under pressure and we’re *all* grumpy (except for those > special insomniacs) when we don’t get enough sleep. > Since the husband is part of the family and (I assume) it was his decision as > well to have the babies, shouldn’t he be part of the solution? It sounds like > he could use some help controlling and dealing with his anger (geez, babies > wake up in the middle of the night, it’s their nature – it’d be like yelling > at an adult for sneezing, totally inappropriate) and maybe a parenting class. > Maybe hubby and wife could get together and figure out a solution that works > for everyone. >  Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he > doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of > refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he > sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that > refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in > some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They > cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and > it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get > blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must > respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure. > > This is a multi-part message in MIME format. > > Content-Type: text/plain; > >  charset="iso-8859-1" > > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > > a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > > but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > > has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > > tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > > them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > > wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > > work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > > top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > > shuts the door. > > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > > dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > > lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > > falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > > room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > > "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > > exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > > that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > > "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > > and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > > i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > > wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > > and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > > them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > > leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > > night. > > any advice would be welcome! > > Content-Type: text/html; > >  charset="iso-8859-1" > > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > > <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD W3 HTML//EN"> > > <HTML> > > <HEAD> > > <META content=3Dtext/html;charset=3Diso-8859-1 = > > http-equiv=3DContent-Type> > > <META content=3D’"MSHTML 4.72.3110.7"’ name=3DGENERATOR> > > </HEAD> > > <BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>here’s my problem and i hope someone = > > can=20 > > help.</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>I married my husband and had twin = > > girls. both=20 > > are 2.5 now.&nbsp; i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons.</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>my husband, at the beginning used to = > > bring the=20 > > twins to bed saying &quot;oh, but they’re so cute&quot;.&nbsp; in the = > > last 5=20 > > months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the = > > twins=20 > > when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution = > > is&nbsp;=20 > > forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the = > > door.&nbsp; </FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had = > > much sleep=20 > > as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband = > > would=20 > > complaint &quot;jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i = > > gotta=20 > > work in the morning!&quot; so i’d get up and give them a bottle.&nbsp;=20 > > </FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last few weeks, he would say &quot;ashley/marissa = > > come in=20 > > here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying&quot;) = > > and=20 > > they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when = > > they toss=20 > > and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed = > > forcefully and=20 > > put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top = > > of his=20 > > lunge &quot;cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!&quot;&nbsp; = > > and=20 > > shuts the door.</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of = > > the=20 > > twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang = > > on to me=20 > > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.&nbsp; in the mean = > > time,=20 > > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > > lay down=20 > > on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling = > > back to=20 > > sleep.&nbsp; in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for = > > marissa=20 > > and that just upset ashely a little where she began to &quot;whine&quot; = > > (this=20 > > took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down = > > completely when my husband, once again, says &quot;ok.. that’s it&quot; = > > and=20 > > YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for &quot;mama&quot; = > > and puts=20 > > her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to=20 > > sleep.&nbsp; i can hear her crying&nbsp; for me for about an = > > hour.</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>i am at wits end. on one hand, he = > > complaints=20 > > when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making = > > them=20 > > upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!&nbsp; = > > there were=20 > > nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping = > > soundly=20 > > next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather = > > than=20 > > waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM&nbsp; = > > at them,=20 > > i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at = > > that=20 > > night.</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>any advice would be welcome!</FONT></DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > > <DIV>&nbsp;</DIV></BODY></HTML> > — > Elaine Gallegos

… read more »

Response:

thank you for your message. he feels that what he’s doing is "correct" and has gotten out of hand. if i go to them and lays down with them he has a fit also… there are times where i wished to be a single parent raising 4 babies and one coming than to continue to allow my children to be yelled and screamed at by this maniac. and yes, i wouldn’t sleep very soundly either! he thinks his behavior is normal.  My other two boys are going thru their preteen and teen years and his reply is "well, look at the way your other kids turned out" as if they are mass murderers and that i do not know how to raise or protect my children :( – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > : here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > : I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > : a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > : my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > : but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > : has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > : tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > : them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > Tantrums, whining, and "upsets" are normal, if undesirable, behavior for > 2.5 year olds. IMO, an adult regularly ‘yelling and screaming’ AT 2.5 year > olds is neither normal nor acceptable. > : when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > : wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > : complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > : work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > : last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > : middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > : the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > : turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > : and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > : top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > : shuts the door. > The way I see it, the poor kids are in a no-win situation. Any waking up > results in moving them to your bed, where what seems to be normal > tossing and turning leads to being screamed at and manhandled by your > husband. Furthermore, I bet that the screaming and arm-yanking > *reinforces* their restless sleep. I certainly wouldn’t sleep soundly if > I was worried about some maniac yelling at me in the middle of the night! > : last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > : crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > : dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > : marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > : lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > : falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > : room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > : "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > : exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > : that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > : "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > : and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > : i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > : up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > : i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > : wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > : and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > : them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > : leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > : night. > I am usually a strong proponent of having parents share ‘getting up’ > duty as much as possible, but in this case you need to protect them from > his abuse. I recommend leaving them in their room and going to sleep > with them if necessary. > You clearly understand that your husband’s behavior is *way* out of hand > and contributing to the problem. Can’t you talk to him and explain that > his actions are making things worse? He also needs to understand that > screaming at and manhandling toddlers in this way is inappropriate, > unacceptable, and just plain abusive, IMO. > Your husband could also benefit from some parenting or anger management > classes. Maybe your pediatrician or local CPS office could recommend a > course that would help. > Laura Uerling

Response:

i actually welcome my daughter’s presence over his at this point in time as i do not care for the way he is screaming at them. we have 5 bedrooms on the 2nd floor, one of which is a guest room.  at this point, i’d rather he move in there and get his sleep than scream at them! i was the one that consistantly said to him that i did not want them in bed to make a habit of it… he was the one that brought them to bed from the start becuz they were "sooooo cute" as he put it. now he made his bed but won’t lay in it! *sighs* thank you for your reply to my message – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >  Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he > doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of > refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he > sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that > refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in > some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They > cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and > it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get > blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must > respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure. > This is a multi-part message in MIME format. > Content-Type: text/plain; >       charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > shuts the door. > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > night. > any advice would be welcome! > Content-Type: text/html; >       charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD W3 HTML//EN"> > <HTML> > <HEAD> > <META content=3Dtext/html;charset=3Diso-8859-1 = > http-equiv=3DContent-Type> > <META content=3D’"MSHTML 4.72.3110.7"’ name=3DGENERATOR> > </HEAD> > <BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>here’s my problem and i hope someone = > can=20 > help.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>I married my husband and had twin = > girls. both=20 > are 2.5 now.&nbsp; i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>my husband, at the beginning used to = > bring the=20 > twins to bed saying &quot;oh, but they’re so cute&quot;.&nbsp; in the = > last 5=20 > months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the = > twins=20 > when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution = > is&nbsp;=20 > forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the = > door.&nbsp; </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had = > much sleep=20 > as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband = > would=20 > complaint &quot;jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i = > gotta=20 > work in the morning!&quot; so i’d get up and give them a bottle.&nbsp;=20 > </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last few weeks, he would say &quot;ashley/marissa = > come in=20 > here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying&quot;) = > and=20 > they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when = > they toss=20 > and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed = > forcefully and=20 > put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top = > of his=20 > lunge &quot;cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!&quot;&nbsp; = > and=20 > shuts the door.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of = > the=20 > twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang = > on to me=20 > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.&nbsp; in the mean = > time,=20 > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down=20 > on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling = > back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for = > marissa=20 > and that just upset ashely a little where she began to &quot;whine&quot; = > (this=20 > took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down = > completely when my husband, once again, says &quot;ok.. that’s it&quot; = > and=20 > YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for &quot;mama&quot; = > and puts=20 > her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; i can hear her crying&nbsp; for me for about an = > hour.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>i am at wits end. on one hand, he = > complaints=20 > when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making = > them=20 > upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!&nbsp; = > there were=20 > nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping = > soundly=20 > next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather = > than=20 > waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM&nbsp; = > at them,=20 > i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at = > that=20 > night.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>any advice would be welcome!</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV>&nbsp;</DIV></BODY></HTML> > — > Elaine Gallegos

Response:

my bed is king size and half of the time we’re at both edges of the bed, with plenty of room for 6 more ppl (smiles) .. if i go to her he has a fit saying i’m "coddling her" and has a screaming fit about it. one time he even literally sat in front of the door of our room so i cannot get out to tend to the babies while they cried. we have a very steep stairs and there wasn’t light on the hall way… i was literally afraid of the girls falling down the stairs since they were out of their rooms that i screamed at him to let me out so that i can prevent them from killing themselves!!! *sighs* – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> I dont know what size there bed is but I got my daughter her twin > bed/bunk beds at that time. My husband was also very intolerant of not > getting sleep and I did just what you said you would do I took > preference of Chiara over him. I began to go sleep in her bed .After a > while she became more comfortable in it and goes to it herself when she > becomes tired. > A child that age, atleast most Ive heard of, want to be by thier mommy > to sleep. I would just climb in her bed with her untill they enjoy > sleeping in it b themselves, that is if life permits. > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also > have a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying > "oh, but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 > months, he has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have > their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully > taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as > they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i > gotta work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at > the top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO > SLEEP!!!!"  and shuts the door. > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean > time, marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly > crying and lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered > herself up and falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move > a little to make room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little > where she began to "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 > minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down completely when my husband, > once again, says "ok.. that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while > she’s screaming now for "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells > her to cover up and shut up and go back to sleep.  i can hear her > crying  for me for about an hour. > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a > kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where > i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next > to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather > than waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM > at them, i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be > screamed at that night. > any advice would be welcome!

Response:

Is your relationship with your husband strained in other ways or is this the main problem in your lives?  Is he abusive to you also?  I wish I could say something to make it better but the only feeling I get is for you to get your children and yourself away from him!! Lorraine Mother of Maxwell & Charlotte (2 yrs) & Madeline (3 mnths) P.S. for specific twin advice are you aware that there is a ng called alt.parenting.twins-triplets ?

Response:

" last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!" and = > shuts the door. >                     "

I would say this man has a control problem. I would also say that this is abuse….I would NOT let him do this to your daughters–this is awful..You need to talk together, away from the girls (can you get a sitter for a couple hours?) and tell him how unacceptable you feel this is..Work out a solution together..Discuss both of your needs in a calm productive manner..Ask him how he thinks the girls feel when he does this..Get him thinking about his actions….Can you put a separate bed for both the girls in your room?? so that they can come in but it is more haronious for all..THis is by NO means excusing this guys behaviour..but that is why I said solution TOGETHER. He may be stressed at work..but who isn’T??  IF this behaviour continues, seek professional help..IF it still continues, GET OUT!!!

Response:

Honey, I am not flaming you, so please bear with me. Your husband sounds as though he is a danger to you and your girls. PLEASE have a plan of action, and take it before someone gets hurt. It is one thing for him to be pissed about being woken, but it is absolutely unacceptable for him to stop you from tending to them. This is abuse, and it has to stop now. See if you can get in touch with a support group for parents of twins, or a Parents Anonymous group nearby. If he will not seek help, you need to find a safe place for you and your kids. In the meantime, if you can find a way to ensure that he gets uninterupted sleep, great. But be safe. Natalie

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->my bed is king size and half of the time we’re at both edges of the bed, with >plenty of room for 6 more ppl (smiles) .. if i go to her he has a fit saying >i’m "coddling her" and has a screaming fit about it. one time he even >literally sat in front of the door of our room so i cannot get out to tend to >the babies while they cried. we have a very steep stairs and there wasn’t >light on the hall way… i was literally afraid of the girls falling down the >stairs since they were out of their rooms that i screamed at him to let me >out so that i can prevent them from killing themselves!!! >*sighs*

Response:

I completely agree that your husband is out of control and his behavior should not be tolerated.  You really need to talk to him or seek some counseling of some sort (parental, psychiatric, whatever).  If you have already talked to him and he won’t cooperate in any manner seek counseling for yourself.   – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > : here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > : I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > : a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > : my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > : but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > : has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > : tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > : them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > Tantrums, whining, and "upsets" are normal, if undesirable, behavior for > 2.5 year olds. IMO, an adult regularly ‘yelling and screaming’ AT 2.5 year > olds is neither normal nor acceptable. > : when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > : wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > : complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > : work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > : last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > : middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > : the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > : turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > : and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > : top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > : shuts the door. > The way I see it, the poor kids are in a no-win situation. Any waking up > results in moving them to your bed, where what seems to be normal > tossing and turning leads to being screamed at and manhandled by your > husband. Furthermore, I bet that the screaming and arm-yanking > *reinforces* their restless sleep. I certainly wouldn’t sleep soundly if > I was worried about some maniac yelling at me in the middle of the night! > : last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > : crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > : dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > : marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > : lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > : falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > : room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > : "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > : exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > : that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > : "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > : and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > : i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > : up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > : i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > : wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > : and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > : them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > : leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > : night. > I am usually a strong proponent of having parents share ‘getting up’ > duty as much as possible, but in this case you need to protect them from > his abuse. I recommend leaving them in their room and going to sleep > with them if necessary. > You clearly understand that your husband’s behavior is *way* out of hand > and contributing to the problem. Can’t you talk to him and explain that > his actions are making things worse? He also needs to understand that > screaming at and manhandling toddlers in this way is inappropriate, > unacceptable, and just plain abusive, IMO. > Your husband could also benefit from some parenting or anger management > classes. Maybe your pediatrician or local CPS office could recommend a > course that would help. > Laura Uerling

Response:

Um, if memory serves, Elaine *doesn’t_have_any_kids*. Please disregard her "advice"! The original post doesn’t state whether or not the Mom in this case is a SAHM or WOHM.  In either situation, Mommy needs to work in the morning  (and noon and night) too.  Responding to night wakings should be a shared responsibility.  Dad’s behaviour is simply not acceptable.  *He* established a pattern of bringing the twins into bed with them.  Responding with anger only establishes an atmosphere of anxiety when it comes to night-time and sleeping.  I think it is essential for him to change his attitude and his approach to one that produces a calm and loving nighttime environment.  When a toddler awakes at night and cannot/has not yet learned to soothe herself back to sleep, it is a parent’s *job* to help her back to dreamland, with a backrub, a lullabye, or soothing words.  The dad needs to learn this lesson NOW before his anger turns to violence.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he >doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of >refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he >sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that >refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in >some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They >cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and >it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get >blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must >respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure.

Response:

> Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he >doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of >refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he >sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that >refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in >some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They >cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and >it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get >blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must >respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure.

This woman’s husband has gone WAY over the line of "grumpy".  I do NOT agree that this man’s violent behavior is a "simple" matter that is getting "blown out of proportion".  He needs anger management intervention ASAP before he injures those babies (or worse).

Response:

: here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. : I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = : a 16 and a 10 year old sons. : my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = : but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = : has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = : tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = : them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 Tantrums, whining, and "upsets" are normal, if undesirable, behavior for 2.5 year olds. IMO, an adult regularly ‘yelling and screaming’ AT 2.5 year olds is neither normal nor acceptable. : when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = : wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = : complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = : work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 : last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = : middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = : the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = : turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = : and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = : top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = : shuts the door. The way I see it, the poor kids are in a no-win situation. Any waking up results in moving them to your bed, where what seems to be normal tossing and turning leads to being screamed at and manhandled by your husband. Furthermore, I bet that the screaming and arm-yanking *reinforces* their restless sleep. I certainly wouldn’t sleep soundly if I was worried about some maniac yelling at me in the middle of the night! : last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = : crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = : dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = : marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = : lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = : falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = : room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = : "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = : exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = : that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = : "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = : and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. : i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = : up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = : i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = : wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = : and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = : them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = : leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = : night. I am usually a strong proponent of having parents share ‘getting up’ duty as much as possible, but in this case you need to protect them from his abuse. I recommend leaving them in their room and going to sleep with them if necessary. You clearly understand that your husband’s behavior is *way* out of hand and contributing to the problem. Can’t you talk to him and explain that his actions are making things worse? He also needs to understand that screaming at and manhandling toddlers in this way is inappropriate, unacceptable, and just plain abusive, IMO. Your husband could also benefit from some parenting or anger management classes. Maybe your pediatrician or local CPS office could recommend a course that would help. Laura Uerling

Response:

Uh, we’re *all* under pressure and we’re *all* grumpy (except for those special insomniacs) when we don’t get enough sleep. Since the husband is part of the family and (I assume) it was his decision as well to have the babies, shouldn’t he be part of the solution? It sounds like he could use some help controlling and dealing with his anger (geez, babies wake up in the middle of the night, it’s their nature – it’d be like yelling at an adult for sneezing, totally inappropriate) and maybe a parenting class. Maybe hubby and wife could get together and figure out a solution that works for everyone. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >  Get those toddlers out of you bed NOW.  Your husband sounds grumpy when he > doesn’t get enough rest, or the babies wake him up.  He needs a place of > refuge. I do not like the way that he is acting with the babies, but he > sounds really desperate for a refuge. Your bedroom or suite should be that > refuge.  Figure out another way to look after the babies at night. Invest in > some extra room insulation, or put their bedroom in another place. They > cannot continue to disturb your husband’s sleep. It’s hurting the babies, and > it hurting your marriage. Do not let a matter this simple to address get > blown out of proportion.  I know that you love your kids, but you must > respect when someone (hubby in this case) is getting too much pressure. > This is a multi-part message in MIME format. > Content-Type: text/plain; >       charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > here’s my problem and i hope someone can help. > I married my husband and had twin girls. both are 2.5 now.  i also have = > a 16 and a 10 year old sons. > my husband, at the beginning used to bring the twins to bed saying "oh, = > but they’re so cute".  in the last 5 months, esp the last 2 months, he = > has been yelling and screaming at the twins when they have their = > tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution is  forcefully taking = > them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the door. =20 > when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had much sleep as they’d = > wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband would = > complaint "jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i gotta = > work in the morning!" so i’d get up and give them a bottle. =20 > last few weeks, he would say "ashley/marissa come in here(this is in = > middle of the night when they’re upset or crying") and they’d come in = > the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when they toss and = > turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed forcefully = > and put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the = > top of his lunge "cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!"  and = > shuts the door. > last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of the twins) came = > crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang on to me for = > dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.  in the mean time, = > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and = > falling back to sleep.  in the mean time, i had to move a little to make = > room for marissa and that just upset ashely a little where she began to = > "whine" (this took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t = > exactly calmed down completely when my husband, once again, says "ok.. = > that’s it" and YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for = > "mama" and puts her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up = > and go back to sleep.  i can hear her crying  for me for about an hour. > i am at wits end. on one hand, he complaints when the babies wakes him = > up. on the other, he screams at them making them upset. if i was a kid, = > i’d have nightmares every night myself!  there were nights where i’d = > wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping soundly next to me = > and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather than waking = > them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM  at them, i’d = > leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at that = > night. > any advice would be welcome! > Content-Type: text/html; >       charset="iso-8859-1" > Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable > <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD W3 HTML//EN"> > <HTML> > <HEAD> > <META content=3Dtext/html;charset=3Diso-8859-1 = > http-equiv=3DContent-Type> > <META content=3D’"MSHTML 4.72.3110.7"’ name=3DGENERATOR> > </HEAD> > <BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>here’s my problem and i hope someone = > can=20 > help.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>I married my husband and had twin = > girls. both=20 > are 2.5 now.&nbsp; i also have a 16 and a 10 year old sons.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>my husband, at the beginning used to = > bring the=20 > twins to bed saying &quot;oh, but they’re so cute&quot;.&nbsp; in the = > last 5=20 > months, esp the last 2 months, he has been yelling and screaming at the = > twins=20 > when they have their tantrums or even whines or is upset. his solution = > is&nbsp;=20 > forcefully taking them upstairs and puts them in their bed and shuts the = > door.&nbsp; </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>when they were babies, i mean BABIES, i hardly had = > much sleep=20 > as they’d wake up every night in middle of the night and my husband = > would=20 > complaint &quot;jesus, do something, give them a bottle or something, i = > gotta=20 > work in the morning!&quot; so i’d get up and give them a bottle.&nbsp;=20 > </FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last few weeks, he would say &quot;ashley/marissa = > come in=20 > here(this is in middle of the night when they’re upset or crying&quot;) = > and=20 > they’d come in the room and get into bed and fall back to sleep. when = > they toss=20 > and turn he’d get all out of shape and yank them out of our bed = > forcefully and=20 > put them back in their beds and screams, LITERALLY SCREAMING, at the top = > of his=20 > lunge &quot;cover up and stop this and GO BACK TO SLEEP!!!!&quot;&nbsp; = > and=20 > shuts the door.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>last night, he did just that… ashely (the older of = > the=20 > twins) came crying in middle of the night.. just got into bed and hang = > on to me=20 > for dear life and i held her back and calmed her down.&nbsp; in the mean = > time,=20 > marissa, her sister was woken up by her and came in slightly crying and = > lay down=20 > on the edge of my side of the bed and covered herself up and falling = > back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; in the mean time, i had to move a little to make room for = > marissa=20 > and that just upset ashely a little where she began to &quot;whine&quot; = > (this=20 > took place all in less than 3 minutes) so she wasn’t exactly calmed down = > completely when my husband, once again, says &quot;ok.. that’s it&quot; = > and=20 > YANKS ashley out of bed while she’s screaming now for &quot;mama&quot; = > and puts=20 > her back into bed and tells her to cover up and shut up and go back to=20 > sleep.&nbsp; i can hear her crying&nbsp; for me for about an = > hour.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2>i am at wits end. on one hand, he = > complaints=20 > when the babies wakes him up. on the other, he screams at them making = > them=20 > upset. if i was a kid, i’d have nightmares every night myself!&nbsp; = > there were=20 > nights where i’d wake up and find ashley or marissa or both sleeping = > soundly=20 > next to me and i’d actually welcome their presence over his! and rather = > than=20 > waking them up and disturbing them and hearing my husband SCREAM&nbsp; = > at them,=20 > i’d leave them next to me. at least i know they won’t be screamed at = > that=20 > night.</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT color=3D#000000 size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2>any advice would be welcome!</FONT></DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV><FONT size=3D2></FONT>&nbsp;</DIV> > <DIV>&nbsp;</DIV></BODY></HTML> > — > Elaine Gallegos

Response:

Question:

: > WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE : > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE : > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS : > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON : > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . : > :  My thought is that I am glad that I’m not your kid. I get the impression : that your child gets hit a lot. Is child protective services on you about it? How on earth did you interpret the post like that? The poster said absolutely *nothing* about their own opinion on the subject, or their own practices if they even have children. Sheesh! Laura Uerling

Response:

Peter, I strongly disagree with you. Teresa

Response:

says… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > : > WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE > : > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE > : > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS > : > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON > : > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . > : > > :  My thought is that I am glad that I’m not your kid. I get the impression > : that your child gets hit a lot. Is child protective services on you about it? > How on earth did you interpret the post like that? The poster said > absolutely *nothing* about their own opinion on the subject, or their > own practices if they even have children. Sheesh! > Laura Uerling

I agree with Luara.  Just because the person left thier capslock on doesn’t mean their children are being beated.  Although the original poster should know that it is considered screaming and some people get bent out of shape about it.  Another thing  where the heck do you get off asking if child protective services are involved???   Ok in answer to the original post.  I thinkk of spanking as a LAST resort.  I only ever use it when my son does something dangerous.  the rest o the time I talk to him or relating things away as a punishment. Stephanie

Response:

WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . — (piller of salt)

Response:

> WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED .

 My thought is that I am glad that I’m not your kid. I get the impression that your child gets hit a lot. Is child protective services on you about it? > — > (piller of salt)

– Elaine Gallegos

Response:

> WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . > — > (piller of salt)

I believe that it differs from child to child, but that there is a very DEFINITE line between spanking and child abuse. Spanking a child on the butt for misbehaving and not hitting so hard that you bruise or break the skin(and yes, you should only use your hand) is not wrong. Taking away priviledges is also good, as long as when this type of "grounding" has a light at the end of the tunnel for the child so that he/she knows what he/she is working towards. I.E. If you ground a child from watching TV or playing video games for say not doing homework or for having a bad attitude, tell them it is for a said period of time,like a week or two, and that they will be reevaluated at the end of that time, and if the behavior has improved, the grounding will be lifted. If not, then they will continue to be grounded for another said period of time. Make sure you have explained fully to the child what it is that they are being disciplined for, and that they understand. If they don’t understand what they did, how to correct the problem etc, discipline will not work, they will just think you are being mean to them. When my kids were growing up, when they would grab at something they weren’t supposed to, they would get a light slap on the hand to get their attention and told no, don’t touch that. My grandma freaked the first time, but when I explained, she understood as well as my kids did. It worked, it only took a couple times before they realized fully what they were supposed to touch and what they weren’t. And that is my opinion…..

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . >  My thought is that I am glad that I’m not your kid. I get the impression > that your child gets hit a lot. Is child protective services on you about it? > — > (piller of salt)

Spanking is not child abuse, and not a reason for CPS to get involved. The only time CPS needs to be involved is when the child is neglected, malnourished, verbally abused(child becomes withdrawn, sullen etc), or physically abused (bruises, cuts, gouges, broken bones etc). Too many people run straight to CPS nowadays over nothing, and CPS reacts accordingly, jumps in, takes the child, and asks questions later. This causes a lot of stress for the family, including and especially the children, only in a lot of cases to find out, that all the parent did was spank the child as a means of discipline. People have spanked their kids for ages, and those kids grew up just fine. SPANKING IS NOT ABUSE UNLESS THE PARENT TAKES IT TOO FAR!!!!! THERE IS A DEFINITIVE LINE BETWEEN THE TWO!!!!!

Response:

Oh No!  Not another spanking thread!  Well, here’s my .02 worth. I personally see spanking as abusive.  It models violent behavior for the child, it deteriorates self esteem, and it doesn’t *teach* the child anything (other than fear of punishment).  I think that working with consequences, both logical, and natural, is a MUCH more effective form of discipline (discipline, by the way, comes from the root word deciple – i.e. a student of a teacher).  If you think only in terms of *punishing* your child for undesirable behavior, then they are not learning WHY the behavior is undesirable.  They are only learning that "ouch, I am going to get hit if I do that again".  What kind of problem solving is this teaching?  That if you can’t get someone to do as you want, you hit them?  When working with logical and natural consequences, I feel that it is much less stressful on the parent, and the child actually learns something AND comes out of the situation with an in tack self esteem.   An example of a LOGICAL consequence might be, say your child refuses to wear his/her seat belt, however, he/she is in a hurry to get to band practice.  You would simply tell them, in a calm voice, "it is unsafe for me to start the car until everyone’s seat belt is fastened"  and STICK TO YOUR WORDS.  If it means they miss practice "oh, well".  If they fasten it, only to unfasten it again, while driving to practice, you could simply pull over and stop the car with very little, or no words (the child will know EXACTLY why you are stopping).  A logical consequence is used when it is not safe to use a NATURAL consequence.  The natural consequence for this situation would be to let the child ride in the car without fastening his/her seat belt and let them get hurt (obviously, NOT the best choice).  This type of parenting, takes work and the results may / may not be as instant as a spanking.  However, your child will learn to make responsible choices on their own, thus learning problem solving skills that will aide them the rest of their lives.  I might add, that your logical consequences need to be in relation to the behavior that you are trying to redirect.  For example, telling the child, "you can’t ride your bike for the next week, if you don’t wear your seatbelt" doesn’t connect. This type of consequence, becomes *punishment* vs. discipline. And that’s my .02 worth! Terri

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE >BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE >PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS >THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON >THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . >– >(piller of salt)

Response:

Terri said: >  I personally see spanking as abusive.

WRONG to spank is to punish for a wrong doing. to abuse is to violate someone else’s rights >It models violent behavior for the child,

WRONG if you put a child over your knee to spank them they will have great difficulty in copying this with other children. >it deteriorates self esteem,

WRONG letting a child get away with bad behaviour/wrong doing is unacceptable >and it doesn’t *teach* the child anything (other than fear >of punishment).

WRONG fear of punishment is the point >I think that working with consequences, both logical, and natural, is a >MUCH more effective form of discipline (discipline, by the way, comes >from the root word deciple – i.e. a student of a teacher).  If you >think only in terms of *punishing* your child for undesirable behavior, >then they are not learning WHY the behavior is undesirable.  They are >only learning that "ouch, I am going to get hit if I do that again".  >What kind of problem solving is this teaching?  

WRONG on several points lets say a child smashes a vase. if the child did it on purpose they should be quickly punished (a small smack on the bottom (fanny in the USA) if the child did it as an accident (you should be able to tell which is which) it should be honest enough to own up. if the child is too young then it’s your fault for leaving a vase wghere it could get broken by a small child. Unacceptable behaviour should be punishable at any age not just childhood. too many people get away with too much verbal and physical abuse because no-one wants to stand up to them. >That if you can’t get someone to do as you want, you hit them?

WRONG that is abuse > When working with logical and natural consequences, I feel that it is >much less stressful on the parent, and the child actually learns >something AND comes out of the situation with an in tack self esteem.  WRONG again

The child needs to learn what the consequencies of their actions are (as above). If they do something good – praise them. >An example of a LOGICAL consequence might be, say your child refuses to >wear his/her seat belt, however, he/she is in a hurry to get to band >practice.  You would simply tell them, in a calm voice, "it is unsafe >for me to start the car until everyone’s seat belt is fastened"  and >STICK TO YOUR WORDS.

WRONG what about telling them it is unlawful to travel in a car without a seatbelt on (i.e. if a policeman spots you you will get told off) >If it means they miss practice "oh, well".  If they fasten it, only to >unfasten it again, while driving to practice, you could simply pull >over and stop the car with very little, or no words (the child will >know EXACTLY why you are stopping).  A logical consequence is used when >it is not safe to use a NATURAL consequence.  The natural consequence >for this situation would be to let the child ride in the car without >fastening his/her seat belt and let them get hurt (obviously, NOT the >best choice).

WRONG see previous paragraph >This type of parenting, takes work and the results may / may not be as >instant as a spanking.  However, your child will learn to make >responsible choices on their own, thus learning problem solving >skills that will aide them the rest of their lives.  

WRONG i can’t beleive you can think like this. Here in the real world children will learn to make responsible choices and make mistakes and learn from them both (same as adults should). >I might add, that your logical consequences need to be in relation to >the behavior that you are trying to redirect.  For example, telling the >child, "you can’t ride your bike for the next week, if you don’t wear >your seatbelt" doesn’t connect..This type of consequence, becomes >*punishment* vs. discipline.

WHAT???? if they don’t wear their seat belt how are you going to go anywhere ? so you’re saying you would take them out without a seatbelt on and if they survive the drive you will punish them later – oh good they will have to think about the loss of a privelige all the time they are out with you, how will that make them feel? >And that’s my .02 worth!

here’s your money back and go get some help. >Terri

peter — Not necessarily  the views on my employer or wife

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > : >If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of > : >the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again. > : I have three kids and believe me sometimes > : a spanking is needed to bring home a point. > I have two children and I have *never* needed to spank them. And I don’t > think, wonderful though they are, that they are so different from > children who parents "need" to spank them. > As for "bringing home a point", in my opinion, spanking *inhibits* > learning because the child focuses on spanking rather than the behavior > it is supposed to discourage. For instance, as I posted earlier, > research on street entries has shown that children who are spanked for > running into the street are actually *more* likely to repeat the > behavior than those who are taught using alternative methods. > : Spanking should only be used as a last resort. > And if it doesn’t work, what then?

I didn’t spank my kids for a simple reason.  When I was spanked I never felt sorry about what I had done — but I hated and resented my parents.  I never wanted to engender that resentment in my own kids.  It also took the focus off of my bad behavior and made me focus on their mean behavior.  And it motivated me to want to ‘get back’ — often in rather sneaky ways. My kids are grown — we get along with them — they are successful they call all the time and get home often — Not knocking them around doeesn’t seem to have caused them any long term problems.

Response:

> WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE > BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR TAKE > PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE HAS > THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON > THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . > — > (piller of salt)

In my opinion there are times when there is no other choice but to spank but that doesnt mean that you beat the child.. But for the most part talking to them or time out is a good way to get through to them… Taking priviledges or adding chores to help for them to learn a lesson is also good… But every child is different.. Some all it takes is a firm voice and they learn.. Others you could spank them and spank them and it doesnt even fase them .. So you have to see what works best for your child… Ztarii4U

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> : >If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of > : >the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again. > : I have three kids and believe me sometimes > : a spanking is needed to bring home a point. > I have two children and I have *never* needed to spank them. And I don’t > think, wonderful though they are, that they are so different from > children who parents "need" to spank them. > As for "bringing home a point", in my opinion, spanking *inhibits* > learning because the child focuses on spanking rather than the behavior > it is supposed to discourage. For instance, as I posted earlier, > research on street entries has shown that children who are spanked for > running into the street are actually *more* likely to repeat the > behavior than those who are taught using alternative methods. > : Spanking should only be used as a last resort. > And if it doesn’t work, what then? > I didn’t spank my kids for a simple reason.  When I was spanked > I never felt sorry about what I had done — but I hated and > resented my parents.  I never wanted to engender that resentment > in my own kids.  It also took the focus off of my bad behavior > and made me focus on their mean behavior.  And it motivated > me to want to ‘get back’ — often in rather sneaky ways. > My kids are grown — we get along with them — they are successful > they call all the time and get home often — Not knocking them > around doeesn’t seem to have caused them any long term problems. > I have 2children a boy 13,who needs keeping in place by a quick slap,and a

girl of 9 who only need’s me to look at her. every child is different  and should be treated as such.

Response:

: >If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of : >the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again. : I have three kids and believe me sometimes : a spanking is needed to bring home a point. I have two children and I have *never* needed to spank them. And I don’t think, wonderful though they are, that they are so different from children who parents "need" to spank them. As for "bringing home a point", in my opinion, spanking *inhibits* learning because the child focuses on spanking rather than the behavior it is supposed to discourage. For instance, as I posted earlier, research on street entries has shown that children who are spanked for running into the street are actually *more* likely to repeat the behavior than those who are taught using alternative methods. : Spanking should only be used as a last resort. And if it doesn’t work, what then? Laura Uerling

Response:

. >If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of >the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again.

I have three kids and believe me sometimes a spanking is needed to bring home a point. Spanking should only be used as a last resort.

Response:

I know a lot of twin parents who don’t go out to friends houses unless the friend also has twins and fully understands the nightmare untwinproofed homes can be. My girls are almost 2 and we can go to most peoples houses for short visits now but I wouldn’t go to a home with lots of breakables. Most of my friends either have kids and understand or they are childless and come to visit me. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I am new to the internet so i don’t know all the tools for doing things like >cross posting.  I described my situation with twin 2 year olds and a new >baby in the newsgroup alt.parenting.twins.triplets recently and asked for >advice on discipline.  Most of the responses were to slap my children. Know >one could give me a good book to read.  I do not want my children to fear me >and would like to find more effective ways to keep them out of danger. They >have a play area 90% babyproofed and that is as good as I can get it.  I >also believe that children should be able to explore without always hearing >no.  I have invested a lot of money to make our living area safer. >     I would also like to know what people do when they visit un >baby-proofed houses.  I had the Thanksgiving from hell at my inlaws this >weekend.  Should I just never go out until these children are ???? years >old.  I am going stir crazy in this house all the time. >     I would appreciate any suggestions.

Response:

Another good one: " Without Spanking or Spoiling: a practical approach to toddler and preschool guidance"  Written by Elizabeth Crary. This one is my all time favorite Margi – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->The following books were suggested to me, though I haven’t had time to >check them out myself. *Blush* >Faber, A. & Mazlish, E. (1980) How to talk so kids will listen and >listen when kids will talk. Avon Books, NY:NY. >Gordon, T. (1989) Discipline that works: Promoting self-discipline in >children. Penguin Books, Inc., NY:NY.

Response:

I have been reading (and re-reading) "The Discipline Book–Everything you need to know to have a better-behaved child–from birth to age ten"  by William Sears, MD and Martha Sears, RN.  I have other books by Dr. Sears and trust his writings.  (In addition to being a doctor, he is the father of eight children.  So he has a little experience.) Hope that helps– Annie

Response:

I was listening to a parenting program on the radio a while back and one of the people on it said something that really made sense to me. They said that we only spank our children when we run out of other ideas on how to discipline them. Their solution was to get as many ideas as you could find to minimize the chances of running out of ideas. I also find that I have to stop myself sometimes when the kids are doing something that I was taught not to do. I give myself a breather and think about why I want to curtail their behavior (obviously this is not an idea when the child is in danger and I am referring to very young children in my case). A lot of the time, I am reacting to what I was taught regardless of the reasonableness of the activity (is it really a big deal if they want to play in that mud puddle?). Once I see that, I can decide for myself if discipline is really in order. I find myself jumping in mud puddles a lot these days. Cheri

Response:

>I was listening to a parenting program on the radio a while back and one of >the people on it said something that really made sense to me. They said that >we only spank our children when we run out of other ideas on how to >discipline them. Their solution was to get as many ideas as you could find >to minimize the chances of running out of ideas.

I agree whole heartedly!  That is why I am so pro parenting education :-)  I think parenting classes, books, etc. give us tools for our parental tool belts.  That way, hopefully, we have loving, healthy alternatives to draw from when we need to disapline our child(ren) ;-) >I also find that I have to stop myself sometimes when the kids are doing >something that I was taught not to do. I give myself a breather and think >about why I want to curtail their behavior (obviously this is not an idea >when the child is in danger and I am referring to very young children in my >case). A lot of the time, I am reacting to what I was taught regardless of >the reasonableness of the activity (is it really a big deal if they want to >play in that mud puddle?). Once I see that, I can decide for myself if >discipline is really in order. I find myself jumping in mud puddles a lot >these days.

Very good point.  Your children are lucky that you are so aware, and can separate your own stuff from their childhood experiences! Terri

Response:

I am new to the internet so i don’t know all the tools for doing things like cross posting.  I described my situation with twin 2 year olds and a new baby in the newsgroup alt.parenting.twins.triplets recently and asked for advice on discipline.  Most of the responses were to slap my children.  Know one could give me a good book to read.  I do not want my children to fear me and would like to find more effective ways to keep them out of danger.  They have a play area 90% babyproofed and that is as good as I can get it.  I also believe that children should be able to explore without always hearing no.  I have invested a lot of money to make our living area safer.      I would also like to know what people do when they visit un baby-proofed houses.  I had the Thanksgiving from hell at my inlaws this weekend.  Should I just never go out until these children are ???? years old.  I am going stir crazy in this house all the time.      I would appreciate any suggestions. Lorraine Mother of Maxwell & Charlotte (2 yrs) & Madeline (4 mnths) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->I was listening to a parenting program on the radio a while back and one of >the people on it said something that really made sense to me. They said >that >we only spank our children when we run out of other ideas on how to >discipline them. Their solution was to get as many ideas as you could find >to minimize the chances of running out of ideas. >I agree whole heartedly!  That is why I am so pro parenting education :-) I >think parenting classes, books, etc. give us tools for our parental tool >belts.  That way, hopefully, we have loving, healthy alternatives to draw >from when we need to disapline our child(ren) ;-) >I also find that I have to stop myself sometimes when the kids are doing >something that I was taught not to do. I give myself a breather and think >about why I want to curtail their behavior (obviously this is not an idea >when the child is in danger and I am referring to very young children in my >case). A lot of the time, I am reacting to what I was taught regardless of >the reasonableness of the activity (is it really a big deal if they want to >play in that mud puddle?). Once I see that, I can decide for myself if >discipline is really in order. I find myself jumping in mud puddles a lot >these days. >Very good point.  Your children are lucky that you are so aware, and can >separate your own stuff from their childhood experiences! >Terri

Response:

After receiving Peter’s flame and re-reading my original post (which I would not choose to change my views on ;-)  ), I feel that my post may have sounded a little b***chy.  My apology to the original poster who was asking advise.  My intent was only to give some friendly advise, and not to flame the original poster in any way.  I guess this "end of pregnancy / I was ready to have this baby YESTERDAY" crankiness is starting to be reflected in my posts!  *LOL* Anyway, "Good luck" to the original poster, hope you get the advise you are looking for :-) Terri – mom to Melissa (3.5 y/o) & Kevin (due ??????? Anytime now) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Oh No!  Not another spanking thread!  Well, here’s my .02 worth. >I personally see spanking as abusive.  It models violent behavior for the >child, it deteriorates self esteem, and it doesn’t *teach* the child >anything (other than fear of punishment).  I think that working with >consequences, both logical, and natural, is a MUCH more effective form of >discipline (discipline, by the way, comes from the root word deciple – i.e. >a student of a teacher).  If you think only in terms of *punishing* your >child for undesirable behavior, then they are not learning WHY the behavior >is undesirable.  They are only learning that "ouch, I am going to get hit if >I do that again".  What kind of problem solving is this teaching?  That if >you can’t get someone to do as you want, you hit them?  When working with >logical and natural consequences, I feel that it is much less stressful on >the parent, and the child actually learns something AND comes out of the >situation with an in tack self esteem.   An example of a LOGICAL consequence >might be, say your child refuses to wear his/her seat belt, however, he/she >is in a hurry to get to band practice.  You would simply tell them, in a >calm voice, "it is unsafe for me to start the car until everyone’s seat belt >is fastened"  and STICK TO YOUR WORDS.  If it means they miss practice "oh, >well".  If they fasten it, only to unfasten it again, while driving to >practice, you could simply pull over and stop the car with very little, or >no words (the child will know EXACTLY why you are stopping).  A logical >consequence is used when it is not safe to use a NATURAL consequence.  The >natural consequence for this situation would be to let the child ride in the >car without fastening his/her seat belt and let them get hurt (obviously, >NOT the best choice).  This type of parenting, takes work and the results >may / may not be as instant as a spanking.  However, your child will learn >to make responsible choices on their own, thus learning problem solving >skills that will aide them the rest of their lives.  I might add, that your >logical consequences need to be in relation to the behavior that you are >trying to redirect.  For example, telling the child, "you can’t ride your >bike for the next week, if you don’t wear your seatbelt" doesn’t connect. >This type of consequence, becomes *punishment* vs. discipline. >And that’s my .02 worth! >Terri >WHAT WOULD YOU VIEW ON THE MATTER BE.  DO YOU BELIVE THAT SPANKING IS THE >BEST METHOD OF DEALING WITHN CHILDREN OR WOULD YOU JUST TALK TO THEM OR >TAKE >PREVLIDGES AWAY.  I KNOW THIS MATTER IS VERY CONTRAVERSIAL AND EVERY ONE >HAS >THEIR OPINION WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT.  YOUR THOUGHTS ON >THIS WOULD BE APRECIATED . >– >(piller of salt)

Response:

Dear Peter, Glad I’m not your child :-) Terri – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Terri said: >  I personally see spanking as abusive. >WRONG >to spank is to punish for a wrong doing. >to abuse is to violate someone else’s rights >It models violent behavior for the child, >WRONG >if you put a child over your knee to spank them they will have great >difficulty in copying this with other children. >it deteriorates self esteem, >WRONG >letting a child get away with bad behaviour/wrong doing is unacceptable >and it doesn’t *teach* the child anything (other than fear >of punishment). >WRONG >fear of punishment is the point >I think that working with consequences, both logical, and natural, is a >MUCH more effective form of discipline (discipline, by the way, comes >from

the root word deciple – i.e. a student of a teacher).  If you >think only in terms of *punishing* your child for undesirable behavior, >then they are not learning WHY the behavior is undesirable.  They are >only learning that "ouch, I am going to get hit if I do that again".  >What kind of problem solving is this teaching? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->WRONG on several points >lets say a child smashes a vase. >if the child did it on purpose they should be quickly punished (a small >smack on the bottom (fanny in the USA) >if the child did it as an accident (you should be able to tell which is >which) it should be honest enough to own up. if the child is too young >then it’s your fault for leaving a vase wghere it could get broken by a >small child. >Unacceptable behaviour should be punishable at any age not just >childhood. too many people get away with too much verbal and physical >abuse because no-one wants to stand up to them. >That if you can’t get someone to do as you want, you hit them? >WRONG >that is abuse > When working with logical and natural consequences, I feel that it is >much less stressful on the parent, and the child actually learns >something

AND comes out of the situation with an in tack self esteem.  WRONG again >The child needs to learn what the consequencies of their actions are (as >above). If they do something good – praise them. >An example of a LOGICAL consequence might be, say your child refuses to >wear his/her seat belt, however, he/she is in a hurry to get to band >practice.  You would simply tell them, in a calm voice, "it is unsafe >for

me to start the car until everyone’s seat belt is fastened"  and >STICK TO YOUR WORDS. >WRONG >what about telling them it is unlawful to travel in a car without a >seatbelt on (i.e. if a policeman spots you you will get told off) >If it means they miss practice "oh, well".  If they fasten it, only to >unfasten it again, while driving to practice, you could simply pull >over

and stop the car with very little, or no words (the child will >know EXACTLY why you are stopping).  A logical consequence is used when >it is not safe to use a NATURAL consequence.  The natural consequence >for this situation would be to let the child ride in the car without >fastening his/her seat belt and let them get hurt (obviously, NOT the >best choice). >WRONG >see previous paragraph >This type of parenting, takes work and the results may / may not be as >instant as a spanking.  However, your child will learn to make >responsible

choices on their own, thus learning problem solving >skills that will aide them the rest of their lives. >WRONG >i can’t beleive you can think like this. Here in the real world children >will learn to make responsible choices and make mistakes and learn from >them both (same as adults should). >I might add, that your logical consequences need to be in relation to >the

behavior that you are trying to redirect.  For example, telling the >child, "you can’t ride your bike for the next week, if you don’t wear >your seatbelt" doesn’t connect..This type of consequence, becomes >*punishment* vs. discipline. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->WHAT???? >if they don’t wear their seat belt how are you going to go anywhere ? >so you’re saying you would take them out without a seatbelt on and if >they survive the drive you will punish them later – oh good they will >have to think about the loss of a privelige all the time they are out >with you, how will that make them feel? >And that’s my .02 worth! >here’s your money back and go get some help. >Terri >peter >– >Not necessarily  the views on my employer or wife

Response:

: This may be wishywashy but it depends on the child and circumstances. : If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of : the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again. : Typically, I find a couch time out to be the most effective for him : (rarely longer than 1 min) when it is a minor infraction/something not : hazardous You’re the second or third person on this thread that’s mentioned spanking only when your child is doing something dangerous. I certainly applaud your efforts at non-spanking discipline, and I think you might be interested to know that there is evidence that swatting in dangerous situations is *not* very effective in preventing repetitions of the dangerous behavior. Someone did a study a few years back of street entries and the effectiveness of different techniques to prevent them. The researcher found that spanking, swatting, etc. is *less* effective than techniques like rewarding safe play and defining safe play zones. Kids who were spanked were *more* likely to run into the street again, especially when a parent is not present. Just some food for thought. :-) Laura Uerling

Response:

This may be wishywashy but it depends on the child and circumstances. If it something dangerous I will spank my son 2yo and hope the shock of the spank will spark the memory if he’s in the situation again. Typically, I find a couch time out to be the most effective for him (rarely longer than 1 min) when it is a minor infraction/something not hazardous

CKBK Go Spartans!! Yeah Michigan State!!

Response:

> Peter, I strongly disagree with you. > Teresa > Teresa,

Since there was no original text in your reply, WHO is Peter?

Response:

Question:

Wow – Moonlight, you’ve written about nearly the exact same problem as I’m having. Thanks for putting a voice to it, and I’m anxious to read the replies. Good luck, Dawn mom to Anthony, 10/15/96 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Can anyone please help me with a rather awkward situation. >I am 29 and my partner is 30 and we have a 10 month old daughter (she is our >first child) and as most new parents, we’re trying to do the best we can. >When I was 19 I had a baby and placed him for adoption.  I handled this >situation very well with support from my family and partner.  It was an open >adoption so I see him a lot, but I have been waiting for 10 years to have >another and when I found out I was pregnant this time it was a very special >surprise. >When I was pregnant with her, I got just about every book on pregnancy and >childcare out of the library so I could have as many ideas, theories and >opinions as possible.  I have had a fair bit to do with children and babies, >but I wanted to be as fully informed as I could.  A lot of these books had >conflicting advice, but with a bit of common sense I have been able to sift >through everything and come up with what I think is a good, sensible and >careful parenting approach. >My problem is with my partner’s sister (who I get along with very well) who >looks after Hannah on the odd occasion.  Her parenting approach is much more >relaxed than mine and sometimes I worry about things happening to Hannah >while she is with her Aunt. She doesn’t seem to take the same care that I do >with day-to-day things, such as dangers around the house and yard, her dog >(who is new and a mix of bull terrier/staffordshire bull terrier) and also >gives Hannah food that I do not for certain reasons. >Am I worrying too much?  I don’t want her to stop staying over with her Aunt >’cos she loves her cousins but at the same time I am concerned. >This must be a universal problem, so if anyone out there can offer any >advice please help me. >Moonlight

Response:

Hi Moonlight! I have a very similar situation with my sister-in-law.  I won’t bore you with the details, however, even though I love her to death and we are very close, our parenting styles vary greatly (of coarse I am the good parent *LOL* – just kidding).  Anyway, my daughter (3.5 y/o) and  her cousin (4.5 y/o) love to play together.  So, what my husband and I have chose to do is not have her babysit for us (we simply make other arrangements), and make a point to get together as a family so the girls can see each other and play. Also, we (my sister-in-law & myself) enrolled in a parenting class together (I found the class and took the "let’s do this together, it will be fun!" approach).  This helped considerably, but, I am still not comfortable with leaving my daughter there while either my husband, or, I are not there to supervise. Just FYI, I have considered talking to her (and my brother in law), however, I don’t think that this would *change* their parenting style (nor do I feel that it is my place to try and *change* them), and I think that it would just cause hurt feelings.  Our children are still very young.  And I know that once my daughter is older she will probably want to go to her cousin’s for sleep overs etc.  Hopefully, by that time, she will be old enough to make responsible decisions for herself and not need quite as much supervision – I guess I’ll just cross that road when I come to it ;-) "Good luck" Terri – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Can anyone please help me with a rather awkward situation. >I am 29 and my partner is 30 and we have a 10 month old daughter (she is our >first child) and as most new parents, we’re trying to do the best we can. >When I was 19 I had a baby and placed him for adoption.  I handled this >situation very well with support from my family and partner.  It was an open >adoption so I see him a lot, but I have been waiting for 10 years to have >another and when I found out I was pregnant this time it was a very special >surprise. >When I was pregnant with her, I got just about every book on pregnancy and >childcare out of the library so I could have as many ideas, theories and >opinions as possible.  I have had a fair bit to do with children and babies, >but I wanted to be as fully informed as I could.  A lot of these books had >conflicting advice, but with a bit of common sense I have been able to sift >through everything and come up with what I think is a good, sensible and >careful parenting approach. >My problem is with my partner’s sister (who I get along with very well) who >looks after Hannah on the odd occasion.  Her parenting approach is much more >relaxed than mine and sometimes I worry about things happening to Hannah >while she is with her Aunt. She doesn’t seem to take the same care that I do >with day-to-day things, such as dangers around the house and yard, her dog >(who is new and a mix of bull terrier/staffordshire bull terrier) and also >gives Hannah food that I do not for certain reasons. >Am I worrying too much?  I don’t want her to stop staying over with her Aunt >’cos she loves her cousins but at the same time I am concerned. >This must be a universal problem, so if anyone out there can offer any >advice please help me. >Moonlight

Response:

>My problem is with my partner’s sister … who looks after Hannah….  Her

parenting approach is much more relaxed than mine and sometimes I worry about things happening to Hannah< I’d get a subscription to Growing Child newsletter and share it with her.  That way you both learn some things, and she doesn’t have to accept your approach, she has only to accept what "experts" are saying.   Especially if it’s only "on occasion" make an issue of only things you perceive as safety concerns.   – Ron Low Levity is the dearth of gravity.  Brevity is the height of clarity.   non-commercial e-mail always welcome Allow 2 days for replies

Response:

Can anyone please help me with a rather awkward situation. I am 29 and my partner is 30 and we have a 10 month old daughter (she is our first child) and as most new parents, we’re trying to do the best we can. When I was 19 I had a baby and placed him for adoption.  I handled this situation very well with support from my family and partner.  It was an open adoption so I see him a lot, but I have been waiting for 10 years to have another and when I found out I was pregnant this time it was a very special surprise. When I was pregnant with her, I got just about every book on pregnancy and childcare out of the library so I could have as many ideas, theories and opinions as possible.  I have had a fair bit to do with children and babies, but I wanted to be as fully informed as I could.  A lot of these books had conflicting advice, but with a bit of common sense I have been able to sift through everything and come up with what I think is a good, sensible and careful parenting approach. My problem is with my partner’s sister (who I get along with very well) who looks after Hannah on the odd occasion.  Her parenting approach is much more relaxed than mine and sometimes I worry about things happening to Hannah while she is with her Aunt. She doesn’t seem to take the same care that I do with day-to-day things, such as dangers around the house and yard, her dog (who is new and a mix of bull terrier/staffordshire bull terrier) and also gives Hannah food that I do not for certain reasons. Am I worrying too much?  I don’t want her to stop staying over with her Aunt ‘cos she loves her cousins but at the same time I am concerned. This must be a universal problem, so if anyone out there can offer any advice please help me. Moonlight

Response:

Gosh, I don’t think you’re worrying too much, this is your baby we’re talking about.  I am the world’s worst when it comes to leaving my kids with anyone.  I only leave them with my mom, or if my 9 year old is at a friend’s house.  But usually I spend the whole time away from them worrying.  (Is my mom watching her closely enough?, Did my mom remember to strap her into her booster chair at the table, ETC ETC…)  So as far as the worrying goes, I think it’s just a normal part of being a mom.  As far as your boyfriends sister goes, I would come right out and let her know what I expect when she’s watching Hannah.  This is your child.  Be nice about it, surely she’ll understand.  If she doesn’t change then only take Hannah over there when you can stay with her.  That way they can visit but you’ll have peace of mind!! Dawn (Taylor and Mackenzie’s mom) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >Can anyone please help me with a rather awkward situation. >I am 29 and my partner is 30 and we have a 10 month old daughter (she is our >first child) and as most new parents, we’re trying to do the best we can. >When I was 19 I had a baby and placed him for adoption.  I handled this >situation very well with support from my family and partner.  It was an open >adoption so I see him a lot, but I have been waiting for 10 years to have >another and when I found out I was pregnant this time it was a very special >surprise. >When I was pregnant with her, I got just about every book on pregnancy and >childcare out of the library so I could have as many ideas, theories and >opinions as possible.  I have had a fair bit to do with children and babies, >but I wanted to be as fully informed as I could.  A lot of these books had >conflicting advice, but with a bit of common sense I have been able to sift >through everything and come up with what I think is a good, sensible and >careful parenting approach. >My problem is with my partner’s sister (who I get along with very well) who >looks after Hannah on the odd occasion.  Her parenting approach is much more >relaxed than mine and sometimes I worry about things happening to Hannah >while she is with her Aunt. She doesn’t seem to take the same care that I do >with day-to-day things, such as dangers around the house and yard, her dog >(who is new and a mix of bull terrier/staffordshire bull terrier) and also >gives Hannah food that I do not for certain reasons. >Am I worrying too much?  I don’t want her to stop staying over with her Aunt >’cos she loves her cousins but at the same time I am concerned. >This must be a universal problem, so if anyone out there can offer any >advice please help me. >Moonlight

Response: