Question:
(hi WTpooh – I thought I had seen you somewhere before! I’m Tribbles from parentsplace!) I happen to agree and think that the point that was made about mom being jealous is a valid one. When hubby comes home from work and she clings to him like a barnacle, you’d think that I was a horrible mother the way she almost won’t have anything to do with me for at least the next couple of hours. But she gets her ‘daddy fix’ and then things even out. To the dad that originated this, just keep hanging in there. You’ll have a wonderful, loving, well-adjusted daughter out of this. maybe a little of just ‘mom and dad’ time would be good to help ward off the ‘mom’s jealous’ thought. good luck! sasha — The Phillips Three (o_ (o_ Almost Heaven West Virginia (/)_ V_/_ V_/_ "The hardest thing to learn in life is which bridge to cross and which to burn." David Russell- phrase of the day, week, month (or however long it takes me to find a new one).
Response:
Make sure your wife isn’t the only one dealing out the limitations and/or punishments. It could be your daughter is associating you with non-punishment or periods when there aren’t any "don’t do thats". Brett http://www.dnaco.net/~bkottman/kristen.html
Response:
Hi, I have a similar problem at my home. My son is 2 and very attached to me. When he was 1 it would go back and forth who hes attachted to. If you wife is jealous maybe she should lighten up a little bit. But don’t take it out on your child because she wants you more. If you pull back, who will be left. People also told me I held my son too much(and still do) but he is the most loveable little boy at age 2. A baby needs all the love it can get, no mattter which parent gives it. Sherry
Response:
As a child therapist I usually hear the opposite…i.e., the child always wants the mother. But the advice is still the same. Recognize that there are differences in how much time and when each parent interacts with the child. There are also different styles of parenting, not to mention personalities that some children respond to differently…IT IS NOTHING PERSONAL. But if parents react to it as personal, then it may reinforce the very behavior that parents wish to stop. This is called negative reinforcement and even small children pick up on it. So don’t over react and find ways to use your own style of parenting and personality to interact with the child. If anyone would like a free handout on parenting tips on disciplining Ron.
Response:
I totally agree with the answer the other person gave below. Our daughter is the same way. She wants to be with daddy all the time when he is home, and doesn’t even like for my husband and I to hug with out her being right in the middle of us. She is just lonely for daddy is all. I am home with her all day long, so when daddy is here it is PLAY TIME!!! She even behaves better for my husband than she does for me. DO NOT stop giving her hugs, kisses, and attention. THAT WOULD BE HORRIBLE!!!!!! Can you imagine what she would think if you stopped??????? You and your wife need to sit down and talk about this. It is VERY common. Every mom I know talks about it. If that doesn’t help, maybe you should talk to the doctor, and he can reassure her. Best Wishes, Shannon – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I think you are doing fine. I think your wife is wrong about why your >daughter behaves the way she does. I think it is a combination of things. >Part of which is the amount of time you and your wife each spend with her. >She sees your wife all day and you for only a couple hours. She misses you >and wants to spend as much time as possible with you while you are home. >Holding and cuddling with her are good things. You should keep it up. I am >sorry you and your wife disagree about this and she really may be a little >jealous of you. I would also encourage your daughter and wife to be more >cuddly toward each other (ask your daughter to go give mommy a hug or a kiss, >and then show her what you mean for her to do; she will learn from your >example and eventually she will be more apt to do it on her own). >Hope this helps a little. Many couples have your problem–you are not alone. >It may also be just a stage in her development and will soon become less of a >problem. >I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When >I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I >come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. >When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to >cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at >times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me. >I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that I am a very >physical person; I love to touch and be touched, whereas my wife is not. >When our daughter was younger (and much lighter), I would frequently carry >her in my arms when we would go shopping or for a walk. My wife says that >I hold her too much and that is why she has become like this. >I should note that my wife spends more time with her than I do; she works >on Saturdays only, and during the week I work eight hours a day at my job >while my wife is at home with the baby. When I get home I play with her >for a couple of hours and then it’s time for bed. >My wife has recently suggested that I not play with her or pick her up when >I come home, but this seems like too extreme a measure. I know that she is >hurt by this behavior, and I don’t want her to feel this way, but on the >other hand I can’t ignore my daughter and feel very good about myself >either. >Any advice from someone who has had a similar experience would be greatly >appreciated. >Michael Rubida >Father to Emily (one year)
When you are a bear of Very Little Brain, and you Think of Things, you find sometimes that a Thing which seemed very Thingish inside you is quite different when it gets out into the open and has other people looking at it. Pooh’s Little Instruction Book
Response:
>I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When >I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I >come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. >When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to >cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at >times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me.
My son (17 mos) enjoys his time with his dad too. Similar situation in that I’m home with him all day while daddy works and daddy likes to "throw him around" and play with him when he is home. I can see where your wife would get jealous, but she must realize that everyone likes a change and you are a change when you come home. Also, since you stated you’re more physical with Emily, your wife must realize that this is why you are preferred. Emily is just doing what’s natural, your wife is the one with the problem. Not playing with her when you come home is not going to solve the problem, it will just make an unhappy baby. One question. When Emily is hurt, who does she go to? Trevor always comes to mom. I’m his comfort object. If Emily goes to mom when she’s hurt the problem in definately your wife’s only. Eventually she will start to "fixate" on her mother. Just let it evolve naturally. Your wife could be more affectionate during the day and let you guys have your fun time at night. You will have a great father/daughter relationship. Nyoka
Response:
Some ideas off the top of my head: 1. Encourage your wife to be more involved with touching during regular family play time. 2. Have your wife do a favourite "thing" during that play time, instead of you e.g. sing a song, play with a toy, or tickle 3. At bedtime, let mommy put her to bed, and let Emily cry herself to sleep. We have done this for different reasons. Our child is asleep within 15 minutes but he soon gets the idea that crying won’t help. 4. You are at work all day, so when you come home it’s "party time". Are there some not-so-favourite things you can do when you get home? Bath time? Change a diaper? Eat peas?
Response:
> I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When > I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I > come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. > When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to > cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at > times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me.
This happened in our family with our two boys. They were both totally fixated on daddy, maybe for the same reasons (he held them constantly when he was home). It did hurt my feelings, too, but they eventually grew out of it and became somewhat equal opportunity. Don’t hold or cuddle your daughter any less, as that would be misunderstood. Just ask your wife to be consistent in whatever she does. Good luck. — Gina
Response:
I think you are doing fine. I think your wife is wrong about why your daughter behaves the way she does. I think it is a combination of things. Part of which is the amount of time you and your wife each spend with her. She sees your wife all day and you for only a couple hours. She misses you and wants to spend as much time as possible with you while you are home. Holding and cuddling with her are good things. You should keep it up. I am sorry you and your wife disagree about this and she really may be a little jealous of you. I would also encourage your daughter and wife to be more cuddly toward each other (ask your daughter to go give mommy a hug or a kiss, and then show her what you mean for her to do; she will learn from your example and eventually she will be more apt to do it on her own). Hope this helps a little. Many couples have your problem–you are not alone. It may also be just a stage in her development and will soon become less of a problem.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – >I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When >I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I >come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. >When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to >cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at >times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me. >I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that I am a very >physical person; I love to touch and be touched, whereas my wife is not. >When our daughter was younger (and much lighter), I would frequently carry >her in my arms when we would go shopping or for a walk. My wife says that >I hold her too much and that is why she has become like this. >I should note that my wife spends more time with her than I do; she works >on Saturdays only, and during the week I work eight hours a day at my job >while my wife is at home with the baby. When I get home I play with her >for a couple of hours and then it’s time for bed. >My wife has recently suggested that I not play with her or pick her up when >I come home, but this seems like too extreme a measure. I know that she is >hurt by this behavior, and I don’t want her to feel this way, but on the >other hand I can’t ignore my daughter and feel very good about myself >either. >Any advice from someone who has had a similar experience would be greatly >appreciated. >Michael Rubida >Father to Emily (one year)
Response:
I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me. I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that I am a very physical person; I love to touch and be touched, whereas my wife is not. When our daughter was younger (and much lighter), I would frequently carry her in my arms when we would go shopping or for a walk. My wife says that I hold her too much and that is why she has become like this. I should note that my wife spends more time with her than I do; she works on Saturdays only, and during the week I work eight hours a day at my job while my wife is at home with the baby. When I get home I play with her for a couple of hours and then it’s time for bed. My wife has recently suggested that I not play with her or pick her up when I come home, but this seems like too extreme a measure. I know that she is hurt by this behavior, and I don’t want her to feel this way, but on the other hand I can’t ignore my daughter and feel very good about myself either. Any advice from someone who has had a similar experience would be greatly appreciated. Michael Rubida Father to Emily (one year)
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->I’m the father of a one year old who has become a total daddy’s girl. When >I’m in the shower, she sits outside the bathroom door and cries until I >come out. At bedtime, if I don’t put her to sleep, she cries and screams. >When we go grocery shopping, if I walk away from the cart she starts to >cry…. This is starting to hurt my wife’s feelings, as it almost seems at >times that our baby is almost totally fixated on me. >I suspect that it may have something to do with the fact that I am a very >physical person; I love to touch and be touched, whereas my wife is not. >When our daughter was younger (and much lighter), I would frequently carry >her in my arms when we would go shopping or for a walk. My wife says that >I hold her too much and that is why she has become like this. >I should note that my wife spends more time with her than I do; she works >on Saturdays only, and during the week I work eight hours a day at my job >while my wife is at home with the baby. When I get home I play with her >for a couple of hours and then it’s time for bed. >My wife has recently suggested that I not play with her or pick her up when >I come home, but this seems like too extreme a measure. I know that she is >hurt by this behavior, and I don’t want her to feel this way, but on the >other hand I can’t ignore my daughter and feel very good about myself >either. >Any advice from someone who has had a similar experience would be greatly >appreciated. >Michael Rubida >Father to Emily (one year)
I’ve been going through something similar to this with our 14-month-old daughter. Though we’re both physical parents, she will go out of her way to be with me … in the kitchen, living room, den… Someone from her day care told me that it’s a phase. And, as I’ve learned from previous responses in this newsgroup to my post about her wanting to be picked up, I just try to roll with it, rather than alter it. Mercedes
Response: